**Irish neutrality, long seen as a guarantee of independence from its former British colonizer, has been eroding under European and Atlantic pressures. After decades of naval weakness, Dublin has committed to strengthening its navy.**
For a long time, the Republic of Ireland believed it was safe, nestled at the western edge of Europe. That sense of security was shattered with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Ranking last in the European Union for defense spending – just 0.2% of GDP, despite posting budget surpluses – Dublin appears to have become a target of Russian hybrid operations. “This vulnerability threatens our success: Without better protection of our infrastructure, foreign investors could decide the risk is too high,” warned Mac Unfraidh.
Incidents have multiplied since 2022. In January of that year, as Moscow was massing troops on the Ukrainian border while denying any intention to invade, the Russian fleet announced maneuvers in the Irish EEZ. “A large Russian squadron arrived in Irish waters on the southwest coast and declared they were going to conduct naval exercises. It was over subsea infrastructure,” recalled Mac Unfraidh. “We understood it at the military level as a signal from the Russians, not just to Ireland, but to Europe, to say that ‘if you interfere with our operation in Ukraine, we can hurt you from the west.'”
The Irish navy had only one operational vessel at the time, which it sent near the area. But it was Irish fishermen who, after sailing out to meet the Russian fleet, claimed responsibility for de-escalating the situation. “For the navy, it was a humiliation,” said Mac Unfraidh. Since then, the threat has grown: The loss of its [Syrian ally](https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2024/12/09/bashar-al-assad-s-downfall-is-a-major-setback-for-russia_6735730_4.html) has closed the Mediterranean route to Russia’s fleet. But according to Mac Unfraidh, “they have confidence that if they come through the Irish waters, their activities won’t be observed to the same degree.”
In light of Ireland’s lackluster response, its European partners have grown impatient. The UK has expressed concern over this newfound vulnerability on its western flank. “Ireland has a responsibility, as does everyone else. No one can be a weak link in our chain of protection,” declared Margrethe Vestager, then vice president of the European Commission, during a visit to Dublin in 2022. With Ireland set to assume the rotating presidency of the European Union on July 1, the coalition government formed by Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, the two main centrist parties, has increasingly come under pressure to strengthen Irish defense and commit the necessary spending.
> The UK has expressed concern over this newfound vulnerability on its western flank. “Ireland has a responsibility, as does everyone else. No one can be a weak link in our chain of protection,” declared Margrethe Vestager, then vice president of the European Commission, during a visit to Dublin in 2022.
Have we so expressed that concern? if so, when? That quote isn’t related; Vestager is a Dane.
I’m quite comfortable with Ireland’s position, and it’s not like they had a dramatically larger naval force throughout the Cold War when the threat from Russia was considerably greater than it is today.
LateInternet9388 on
Ireland’s GDP is a nonsense, so using “Ranking last in the European Union for defense spending – just 0.2% of GDP” to complain about its defense spending is also a nonsense.
shorelined on
The article is still paywalled so I can’t determine whether the “Incidents have multiplied since 2022” gets explained as a multiplication that is far higher than any other country, or if the overall rate is anywhere near any other country. Besides, to quote GDP of all things to criticise Irish defence spending when the EU has been pushing Ireland to increase corporation tax returns for the last decade is frankly a crap argument.
I live in Ireland and the defence forces are indeed sorely underfunded, but I’m willing to bet there are much weaker links like Europe’s continued reliance on Russian resources, various countries where governing political parties are controlled by Russian assets, or where other countries are undergoing sustained hybrid warfare campaigns too.
SraminiElMejorBeaver on
>**Irish neutrality, long seen as a guarantee of independence from its former British colonizer, has been eroding under European and Atlantic pressures. After decades of naval weakness, Dublin has committed to strengthening its navy.**
>In Cobh, in the south of Ireland, just a few kilometers from Cork city, the waterfront promenade offers a stunning view of Haulbowline Island, the main base of the Irish Naval Service, the country’s navy. On a day at the end of February, beneath rain clouds streaking across the horizon, black and white boats made constant trips back and forth, transporting military personnel. “You can make out a Martello tower [a small fortress built at the start of the 19th century], built by the British to prevent the risk of a Napoleonic invasion. And you can see the masts of four of our patrol vessels,” said Caoimhin Mac Unfraidh, a naval officer, pointing out the island.
>Mac Unfraidh was once the commander of the LE Eithne, a helicopter carrier in the Irish fleet that was decommissioned at the end of 2022 after 38 years of service. Retired since 2023, the fifty-something was watching Haulbowline Island from the shore, torn between pride and bitterness. “My personal story is part of the overall picture. I left because I had reached almost the highest rank I could, because the navy is so small. The number of ships was falling and they weren’t being replaced,” he explained.
>”The navy has currently eight ships, of which about three or four are currently operational. These are patrol vessels, they don’t have subsurface surveillance capability, they don’t have a credible air defense capability,” explained Vice Admiral Mark Mellett, who served as chief of staff of the Irish Defence Forces, the country’s military, until 2021. In addition, there are two maritime patrol aircraft and fewer than 900 active personnel. These are modest resources for an island nation with an exclusive economic zone (EEZ) covering 450,000 square kilometers in the North Atlantic, and tasked with protecting major national and international economic interests, both on land and at sea.
>Ireland, once one of the poorest countries in Europe, has undergone a transformation thanks to an attractive tax system, an English-speaking workforce, and its entry into the European Union (EU) in 1973, attracting major American pharmaceutical and high-tech companies. “One third of all of Europe’s internet data is held in data centers in Ireland. Those data centers are powered by electricity. Overwhelmingly, that electricity comes from gas. Almost all of our gas comes from three pipelines from the United Kingdom,” explained Cian FitzGerald, a defense expert at the Institute of International and European Affairs in Dublin. Nearly three-quarters of the Northern Hemisphere’s undersea telecommunications cables pass through, skirt, or cross Irish waters, according to the Center for Strategic and International Studies. A single outage could severely disrupt large sectors of the Irish economy, as well as those of Europe and North America.
>**Incidents involving the Russian fleet**
>For a long time, the Republic of Ireland believed it was safe, nestled at the western edge of Europe. That sense of security was shattered with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Ranking last in the European Union for defense spending – just 0.2% of GDP, despite posting budget surpluses – Dublin appears to have become a target of Russian hybrid operations. “This vulnerability threatens our success: Without better protection of our infrastructure, foreign investors could decide the risk is too high,” warned Mac Unfraidh.
>Incidents have multiplied since 2022. In January of that year, as Moscow was massing troops on the Ukrainian border while denying any intention to invade, the Russian fleet announced maneuvers in the Irish EEZ. “A large Russian squadron arrived in Irish waters on the southwest coast and declared they were going to conduct naval exercises. It was over subsea infrastructure,” recalled Mac Unfraidh. “We understood it at the military level as a signal from the Russians, not just to Ireland, but to Europe, to say that ‘if you interfere with our operation in Ukraine, we can hurt you from the west.'”
>The Irish navy had only one operational vessel at the time, which it sent near the area. But it was Irish fishermen who, after sailing out to meet the Russian fleet, claimed responsibility for de-escalating the situation. “For the navy, it was a humiliation,” said Mac Unfraidh. Since then, the threat has grown: The loss of its [Syrian ally]() has closed the Mediterranean route to Russia’s fleet. But according to Mac Unfraidh, “they have confidence that if they come through the Irish waters, their activities won’t be observed to the same degree.”
>The Yantar, a Russian spy ship with advanced underwater surveillance capabilities, has since been spotted several times off the coast of Ireland. In mid-2023, according to the *Irish Examiner*, a Russian submarine also ventured to the entrance of Cork harbor, chased away by a British helicopter and warship. “I sat on the EU Military Committee [which advises Brussels on defense matters] for six years [2015-2021] and one of our discussion points was Russia’s ability to have forces on eastern Ukraine and forces to the west coast of Ireland,” said Mellett. The most recent alert was when drones were spotted on the flight path of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s plane as he arrived in Dublin on an official visit in December 2025.
>In light of Ireland’s lackluster response, its European partners have grown impatient. The UK has expressed concern over this newfound vulnerability on its western flank. “Ireland has a responsibility, as does everyone else. No one can be a weak link in our chain of protection,” declared Margrethe Vestager, then vice president of the European Commission, during a visit to Dublin in 2022. With Ireland set to assume the rotating presidency of the European Union on July 1, the coalition government formed by Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, the two main centrist parties, has increasingly come under pressure to strengthen Irish defense and commit the necessary spending.
hmmm_ on
I’d ignore the choice of President, she became the default option when the other candidates self destructed. The President doesn’t have a lot of power in Ireland.
Sciprio on
Ireland joined an economic union, not a defence union and was given assurances second time round after passing the Lisbon Treaty (Rejected first time)
The assurances were that Ireland could maintain its own defence and tax matters, those two are now being chipped away at. NATO and Russia like to play games off of each other’s borders, Russia comes around Ireland for that reason also. We just happen to be in the way.
These articles are being pumped out to pressure Ireland into spending more on buying weapons from international military industry, in the future cuts will have to be made, and after they’ve got people used to the defence spending increases, they’ll cut back on public services just so defence can be increased or maintained.
>”**We understood it at the military level as a signal from the Russians, not just to Ireland, but to Europe, to say that ‘if you interfere with our operation in Ukraine, we can hurt you from the west**.'”
And that’s it, the Russians are returning the favour.
sebjoh on
Ireland has long been able to freeload on its militarily strong neighbor (the UK), without any formal alliance but with the knowledge that the UK would oppose any attempt by other powers to take or blockade Ireland. But now the UK military is much too small to do anything but to participate as a member of an alliance. Ireland is not in that alliance and so the UK can not defend Ireland. Ireland must invest in its own defenses.
OldRepresentative578 on
The Irish defence forces are rarely much of a priority for Irish politicians or voters, and it shows.
Yea i mean if you are in the EU you are not really neutral.
drunkandhotboy on
Joining a military alliance with the likes of the Germans and French would only increase the chances of a country attacking Ireland.
Ireland is very reliant on globalisation and thus, a relatively peaceful world, the more neutral parties there are, and the less belligerents, the more people there are to call for peace
helpnxt on
Without reading into it, probably but the UK would 100% step in and back them. For all the bad blood between Ireland and the UK if we abandoned Ireland when needed it would destroy any government as the vast vast majority of UK citizens love the Irish
redd1618 on
so they have to sink Russian ships with their kerry gold canons
SpareZealousideal740 on
There’s probably a limit in how much we can realistically spend on defence for it to actually be useful.
We’re never going to have a huge naval, army or airforce, and we’re not an easily defendable location if UK or US were our enemies (and anyone else as our enemy has to go through them anyway) but I do think we should be putting a good chunk more into cyber security, special forces (Army Ranger Wing), coastguard and on detection.
OkKnowledge2064 on
Europe has a lot of weak links
PhotoNext3321 on
For all of the criticisms of Irish neutrality (most of which I agree with), I would like to see a bit of counterbalance in the reporting. Neutrality *has* been very successful for Ireland. It has faced much less hostile rhetoric from aggressive countries, and it avoided ISIS terror attacks due to the perception it is not aligned with countries which have gone adventuring in the middle east.. The article mentioned how incidents have multiplied, but none have actually materialised as an attack, with the exception of the HSE hack a few years ago.
And another issue is that even if Ireland massively invested in its defence, that does not imply they should abandon neutrality.
Anyway, my personal view is that Ireland should join an EU defence union, and invest in its navy and air corps – I just don’t feel that any of the articles on this topic have actually made good arguments for that case.
technocraticnihilist on
Let’s be honest, Ireland is not under threat by any country, including Russia, and they’re not a nato member
mrlinkwii on
so what , the EU is not a military alliance
SeriesDowntown5947 on
Understatement. There’s no llink.
mrlinkwii on
i see its the weekly neutrality bad article
juksbox on
There are three types of countries in Europe:
– Allied countries
– Countries that are not in the alliance but would like to be
– Countries that are not allied and do not want to be but are free riders for the allied countries.
ShowmasterQMTHH on
Le monde spam.
shiningdickhalloran on
The guy who wrote this has never seen an Irishman in a bar fight.
tonyedit on
Ireland – 7 million people across the island. Natural resources – Sheep and cows, wind and rain. Strategic resources – Internet cables and data centres. A bit too close to major western European powers geographically for their comfort. Defence spending – An embarrassment. Defence philosophy – Yerra, it’ll be grand. Probably not our fight anyway. Likelihood of change – Not with the useless shower of pricks we have in government at the moment. Also, no evidence of a foreign powers will to invade or influence our nation bar our long history with our immediate neighbour. Long and short – We’re a bit of a joke but sure, what military would want to bother anyway.
zestinglemon on
Ireland doesn’t need to join NATO or an EU defence treaty but surely it’s beneficial to have the bare minimum defences to defend itself. Such as maybe a single Squadron of fighters to intercept military threats, naval threats and unidentified aircraft. Or a Navy that can defend its own waters and protect internationally important undersea cables. Having a security service and army that could protect against potential terror attacks would also be beneficial.
Nobody expects Ireland to have to defend itself against a full on invasion (not that it wouldn’t be advantageous to have the foundations to be able to do that should the global defence landscape change in the near future, like with the climate crisis). It is entirely possible however that Ireland could be at threat from Russian sabotage, we’ve seen this already in fact with Russian ships attempting to mess with undersea cables and intruding in Irish waters. Hybrid warfare is something Russia has been experimenting and investing in increasingly with Ireland possibly being a favourable target in the near future with its weak defences but close proximity to the UK, being an important player in the EU and the headquarters of many big American and global businesses.
Not least as a Brit, whilst I have no issue with us assisting a neighbour and friend, it would be nice if Ireland could defend itself and not have to largely rely on us all the time. Surely it’s in Irelands best interest too as I doubt many Irish people would be proud about having to rely on its former coloniser to defend them. Additionally, our government could strictly speaking use the matter of Irish defence as a playing card in diplomatic discussions. I woudnt agree with that personally but for as long as it is possible, our government certainly could take advantage (especially thinking about a possible reform or restore government).
27 commenti
**Irish neutrality, long seen as a guarantee of independence from its former British colonizer, has been eroding under European and Atlantic pressures. After decades of naval weakness, Dublin has committed to strengthening its navy.**
For a long time, the Republic of Ireland believed it was safe, nestled at the western edge of Europe. That sense of security was shattered with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Ranking last in the European Union for defense spending – just 0.2% of GDP, despite posting budget surpluses – Dublin appears to have become a target of Russian hybrid operations. “This vulnerability threatens our success: Without better protection of our infrastructure, foreign investors could decide the risk is too high,” warned Mac Unfraidh.
Incidents have multiplied since 2022. In January of that year, as Moscow was massing troops on the Ukrainian border while denying any intention to invade, the Russian fleet announced maneuvers in the Irish EEZ. “A large Russian squadron arrived in Irish waters on the southwest coast and declared they were going to conduct naval exercises. It was over subsea infrastructure,” recalled Mac Unfraidh. “We understood it at the military level as a signal from the Russians, not just to Ireland, but to Europe, to say that ‘if you interfere with our operation in Ukraine, we can hurt you from the west.'”
The Irish navy had only one operational vessel at the time, which it sent near the area. But it was Irish fishermen who, after sailing out to meet the Russian fleet, claimed responsibility for de-escalating the situation. “For the navy, it was a humiliation,” said Mac Unfraidh. Since then, the threat has grown: The loss of its [Syrian ally](https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2024/12/09/bashar-al-assad-s-downfall-is-a-major-setback-for-russia_6735730_4.html) has closed the Mediterranean route to Russia’s fleet. But according to Mac Unfraidh, “they have confidence that if they come through the Irish waters, their activities won’t be observed to the same degree.”
In light of Ireland’s lackluster response, its European partners have grown impatient. The UK has expressed concern over this newfound vulnerability on its western flank. “Ireland has a responsibility, as does everyone else. No one can be a weak link in our chain of protection,” declared Margrethe Vestager, then vice president of the European Commission, during a visit to Dublin in 2022. With Ireland set to assume the rotating presidency of the European Union on July 1, the coalition government formed by Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, the two main centrist parties, has increasingly come under pressure to strengthen Irish defense and commit the necessary spending.
**Read the full article here:** [**https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2026/04/19/ireland-the-weak-link-in-europe-s-defense_6752596_4.html**](https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2026/04/19/ireland-the-weak-link-in-europe-s-defense_6752596_4.html)
> The UK has expressed concern over this newfound vulnerability on its western flank. “Ireland has a responsibility, as does everyone else. No one can be a weak link in our chain of protection,” declared Margrethe Vestager, then vice president of the European Commission, during a visit to Dublin in 2022.
Have we so expressed that concern? if so, when? That quote isn’t related; Vestager is a Dane.
I’m quite comfortable with Ireland’s position, and it’s not like they had a dramatically larger naval force throughout the Cold War when the threat from Russia was considerably greater than it is today.
Ireland’s GDP is a nonsense, so using “Ranking last in the European Union for defense spending – just 0.2% of GDP” to complain about its defense spending is also a nonsense.
The article is still paywalled so I can’t determine whether the “Incidents have multiplied since 2022” gets explained as a multiplication that is far higher than any other country, or if the overall rate is anywhere near any other country. Besides, to quote GDP of all things to criticise Irish defence spending when the EU has been pushing Ireland to increase corporation tax returns for the last decade is frankly a crap argument.
I live in Ireland and the defence forces are indeed sorely underfunded, but I’m willing to bet there are much weaker links like Europe’s continued reliance on Russian resources, various countries where governing political parties are controlled by Russian assets, or where other countries are undergoing sustained hybrid warfare campaigns too.
>**Irish neutrality, long seen as a guarantee of independence from its former British colonizer, has been eroding under European and Atlantic pressures. After decades of naval weakness, Dublin has committed to strengthening its navy.**
>In Cobh, in the south of Ireland, just a few kilometers from Cork city, the waterfront promenade offers a stunning view of Haulbowline Island, the main base of the Irish Naval Service, the country’s navy. On a day at the end of February, beneath rain clouds streaking across the horizon, black and white boats made constant trips back and forth, transporting military personnel. “You can make out a Martello tower [a small fortress built at the start of the 19th century], built by the British to prevent the risk of a Napoleonic invasion. And you can see the masts of four of our patrol vessels,” said Caoimhin Mac Unfraidh, a naval officer, pointing out the island.
>Mac Unfraidh was once the commander of the LE Eithne, a helicopter carrier in the Irish fleet that was decommissioned at the end of 2022 after 38 years of service. Retired since 2023, the fifty-something was watching Haulbowline Island from the shore, torn between pride and bitterness. “My personal story is part of the overall picture. I left because I had reached almost the highest rank I could, because the navy is so small. The number of ships was falling and they weren’t being replaced,” he explained.
>”The navy has currently eight ships, of which about three or four are currently operational. These are patrol vessels, they don’t have subsurface surveillance capability, they don’t have a credible air defense capability,” explained Vice Admiral Mark Mellett, who served as chief of staff of the Irish Defence Forces, the country’s military, until 2021. In addition, there are two maritime patrol aircraft and fewer than 900 active personnel. These are modest resources for an island nation with an exclusive economic zone (EEZ) covering 450,000 square kilometers in the North Atlantic, and tasked with protecting major national and international economic interests, both on land and at sea.
>Ireland, once one of the poorest countries in Europe, has undergone a transformation thanks to an attractive tax system, an English-speaking workforce, and its entry into the European Union (EU) in 1973, attracting major American pharmaceutical and high-tech companies. “One third of all of Europe’s internet data is held in data centers in Ireland. Those data centers are powered by electricity. Overwhelmingly, that electricity comes from gas. Almost all of our gas comes from three pipelines from the United Kingdom,” explained Cian FitzGerald, a defense expert at the Institute of International and European Affairs in Dublin. Nearly three-quarters of the Northern Hemisphere’s undersea telecommunications cables pass through, skirt, or cross Irish waters, according to the Center for Strategic and International Studies. A single outage could severely disrupt large sectors of the Irish economy, as well as those of Europe and North America.
>**Incidents involving the Russian fleet**
>For a long time, the Republic of Ireland believed it was safe, nestled at the western edge of Europe. That sense of security was shattered with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Ranking last in the European Union for defense spending – just 0.2% of GDP, despite posting budget surpluses – Dublin appears to have become a target of Russian hybrid operations. “This vulnerability threatens our success: Without better protection of our infrastructure, foreign investors could decide the risk is too high,” warned Mac Unfraidh.
>Incidents have multiplied since 2022. In January of that year, as Moscow was massing troops on the Ukrainian border while denying any intention to invade, the Russian fleet announced maneuvers in the Irish EEZ. “A large Russian squadron arrived in Irish waters on the southwest coast and declared they were going to conduct naval exercises. It was over subsea infrastructure,” recalled Mac Unfraidh. “We understood it at the military level as a signal from the Russians, not just to Ireland, but to Europe, to say that ‘if you interfere with our operation in Ukraine, we can hurt you from the west.'”
>The Irish navy had only one operational vessel at the time, which it sent near the area. But it was Irish fishermen who, after sailing out to meet the Russian fleet, claimed responsibility for de-escalating the situation. “For the navy, it was a humiliation,” said Mac Unfraidh. Since then, the threat has grown: The loss of its [Syrian ally]() has closed the Mediterranean route to Russia’s fleet. But according to Mac Unfraidh, “they have confidence that if they come through the Irish waters, their activities won’t be observed to the same degree.”
>The Yantar, a Russian spy ship with advanced underwater surveillance capabilities, has since been spotted several times off the coast of Ireland. In mid-2023, according to the *Irish Examiner*, a Russian submarine also ventured to the entrance of Cork harbor, chased away by a British helicopter and warship. “I sat on the EU Military Committee [which advises Brussels on defense matters] for six years [2015-2021] and one of our discussion points was Russia’s ability to have forces on eastern Ukraine and forces to the west coast of Ireland,” said Mellett. The most recent alert was when drones were spotted on the flight path of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s plane as he arrived in Dublin on an official visit in December 2025.
>In light of Ireland’s lackluster response, its European partners have grown impatient. The UK has expressed concern over this newfound vulnerability on its western flank. “Ireland has a responsibility, as does everyone else. No one can be a weak link in our chain of protection,” declared Margrethe Vestager, then vice president of the European Commission, during a visit to Dublin in 2022. With Ireland set to assume the rotating presidency of the European Union on July 1, the coalition government formed by Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, the two main centrist parties, has increasingly come under pressure to strengthen Irish defense and commit the necessary spending.
I’d ignore the choice of President, she became the default option when the other candidates self destructed. The President doesn’t have a lot of power in Ireland.
Ireland joined an economic union, not a defence union and was given assurances second time round after passing the Lisbon Treaty (Rejected first time)
The assurances were that Ireland could maintain its own defence and tax matters, those two are now being chipped away at. NATO and Russia like to play games off of each other’s borders, Russia comes around Ireland for that reason also. We just happen to be in the way.
These articles are being pumped out to pressure Ireland into spending more on buying weapons from international military industry, in the future cuts will have to be made, and after they’ve got people used to the defence spending increases, they’ll cut back on public services just so defence can be increased or maintained.
>”**We understood it at the military level as a signal from the Russians, not just to Ireland, but to Europe, to say that ‘if you interfere with our operation in Ukraine, we can hurt you from the west**.'”
And that’s it, the Russians are returning the favour.
Ireland has long been able to freeload on its militarily strong neighbor (the UK), without any formal alliance but with the knowledge that the UK would oppose any attempt by other powers to take or blockade Ireland. But now the UK military is much too small to do anything but to participate as a member of an alliance. Ireland is not in that alliance and so the UK can not defend Ireland. Ireland must invest in its own defenses.
The Irish defence forces are rarely much of a priority for Irish politicians or voters, and it shows.
https://www.rte.ie/news/analysis-and-comment/2025/1213/1548811-defence-spending-plan/
https://www.breakingnews.ie/ireland/glaring-gaps-in-irelands-defence-remain-as-defence-forces-numbers-fall-to-7500-1614929.html
https://www.thejournal.ie/commission-on-the-defence-forces-road-map-to-modernisation-5678488-Feb2022/
🇮🇪🤝🏻🇦🇹
[deleted]
Yea i mean if you are in the EU you are not really neutral.
Joining a military alliance with the likes of the Germans and French would only increase the chances of a country attacking Ireland.
Ireland is very reliant on globalisation and thus, a relatively peaceful world, the more neutral parties there are, and the less belligerents, the more people there are to call for peace
Without reading into it, probably but the UK would 100% step in and back them. For all the bad blood between Ireland and the UK if we abandoned Ireland when needed it would destroy any government as the vast vast majority of UK citizens love the Irish
so they have to sink Russian ships with their kerry gold canons
There’s probably a limit in how much we can realistically spend on defence for it to actually be useful.
We’re never going to have a huge naval, army or airforce, and we’re not an easily defendable location if UK or US were our enemies (and anyone else as our enemy has to go through them anyway) but I do think we should be putting a good chunk more into cyber security, special forces (Army Ranger Wing), coastguard and on detection.
Europe has a lot of weak links
For all of the criticisms of Irish neutrality (most of which I agree with), I would like to see a bit of counterbalance in the reporting. Neutrality *has* been very successful for Ireland. It has faced much less hostile rhetoric from aggressive countries, and it avoided ISIS terror attacks due to the perception it is not aligned with countries which have gone adventuring in the middle east.. The article mentioned how incidents have multiplied, but none have actually materialised as an attack, with the exception of the HSE hack a few years ago.
And another issue is that even if Ireland massively invested in its defence, that does not imply they should abandon neutrality.
Anyway, my personal view is that Ireland should join an EU defence union, and invest in its navy and air corps – I just don’t feel that any of the articles on this topic have actually made good arguments for that case.
Let’s be honest, Ireland is not under threat by any country, including Russia, and they’re not a nato member
so what , the EU is not a military alliance
Understatement. There’s no llink.
i see its the weekly neutrality bad article
There are three types of countries in Europe:
– Allied countries
– Countries that are not in the alliance but would like to be
– Countries that are not allied and do not want to be but are free riders for the allied countries.
Le monde spam.
The guy who wrote this has never seen an Irishman in a bar fight.
Ireland – 7 million people across the island. Natural resources – Sheep and cows, wind and rain. Strategic resources – Internet cables and data centres. A bit too close to major western European powers geographically for their comfort. Defence spending – An embarrassment. Defence philosophy – Yerra, it’ll be grand. Probably not our fight anyway. Likelihood of change – Not with the useless shower of pricks we have in government at the moment. Also, no evidence of a foreign powers will to invade or influence our nation bar our long history with our immediate neighbour. Long and short – We’re a bit of a joke but sure, what military would want to bother anyway.
Ireland doesn’t need to join NATO or an EU defence treaty but surely it’s beneficial to have the bare minimum defences to defend itself. Such as maybe a single Squadron of fighters to intercept military threats, naval threats and unidentified aircraft. Or a Navy that can defend its own waters and protect internationally important undersea cables. Having a security service and army that could protect against potential terror attacks would also be beneficial.
Nobody expects Ireland to have to defend itself against a full on invasion (not that it wouldn’t be advantageous to have the foundations to be able to do that should the global defence landscape change in the near future, like with the climate crisis). It is entirely possible however that Ireland could be at threat from Russian sabotage, we’ve seen this already in fact with Russian ships attempting to mess with undersea cables and intruding in Irish waters. Hybrid warfare is something Russia has been experimenting and investing in increasingly with Ireland possibly being a favourable target in the near future with its weak defences but close proximity to the UK, being an important player in the EU and the headquarters of many big American and global businesses.
Not least as a Brit, whilst I have no issue with us assisting a neighbour and friend, it would be nice if Ireland could defend itself and not have to largely rely on us all the time. Surely it’s in Irelands best interest too as I doubt many Irish people would be proud about having to rely on its former coloniser to defend them. Additionally, our government could strictly speaking use the matter of Irish defence as a playing card in diplomatic discussions. I woudnt agree with that personally but for as long as it is possible, our government certainly could take advantage (especially thinking about a possible reform or restore government).