But everyone assured me he was going to “smash the gangs” and that Labour were on top of it?
thehighyellowmoon on
It’s a big problem and the solution will need patience to fix, otherwise we’ll end up with Skiver-in-Chief as PM with the party who claim the solution is simple and legal yet won’t publish their own legal advice.
John_Williams_1977 on
The speed of light can’t be changed by us mere mortals.
Laws relating to asylum, benefits etc.? They can.
All this persists because Labour and Conservative governments want it too.
Imagine pretending a huge parliamentary majority – and the ability to introduce and conclude legislation on a single Saturday morning – isn’t enough.
Maybe prayer then?
BabuFrikDroidsmith on
Bombs land in iran. More Iranians cross channel. Simples
corbynista2029 on
>Meeting on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Canada, Sir Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron agreed to “work closely” to tackle crossings, a No 10 spokesperson said.
Starmer need to sign a returns agreement with France and set up a processing center in Calais ASAP. If people can apply for asylum from France, they won’t cross the channel. If they know that they will be returned to France, they won’t cross either. The reason practically no one crossed the channel before Brexit is because of this returns agreement. Without it Starmer won’t solve the problem.
GhostRiders on
Whilst people believe that they can have a easier time in the UK they will keep coming, no deal the UK strikes with France will stop this.
The only way to stop this is to implement changes and rules that make coming to the UK not worth risking your life over.
I’ve said it before and I will say it again, we need to have Migrant Centres where anybody arriving illegal by any methods are sent to and can not leave until their application has been processed and accepted.
Everyone else will be sent back.
Whilst at the centre all their medical needs will be seen to and they will have a safe warm place to sleep and eat.
They don’t need anything else.
This will stop the majority of economic migrants as they will not be able to earn any money for months and they can’t just disappear.
It will have a massive impact on people taking advantage of those here illegally, Factories, Car Washers, Fast Food Take Aways, Delivery Drivers Uber Drivers etc..
This will also help reduce the strain on local councils and public services.
It is a win, win situation and also done in quite a few European Countries.
From a purely cynical point of view it is a garratueed vote winner and will pretty much put an end to Reform.
Labour desperately need to grow a set of balls and announce the building of Migrant Centres.
Wiggles114 on
Arrest those landing not at a port.
Detain them in designated facilities (not hotels), such as cordoned inside military areas, within fences, under guard, provided with shelter (tents), running water, hygiene facilities, and provisions (out of date combat rations).
Bring the home office staff there, so they can process the asylum claims in situ.
If granted asylum let out, even provide a coach to a Jobcentre that’s struggling to recruit.
If not granted asylum, deport, and record for immediate deportation should they attempt re-entry.
I won’t even charge the £25m consulting fee that Deloitte would have to produce this outline.
MetalChaotic on
If we end up at war with someone, are we still going to allow potential enemies in via this route?
chihuahuajoe on
Now Iran is going to be bombed to smithereens, it will be 10 times worse, cheers Donald.
Univeralise on
An interesting thing is typically the differences on how the French process goes compared to the UK.
This is going to be a wall of text but I’m just comparing the two and you’ll see why it’s rising.
For example, France demand more documentation early on in the process and when asked for documents and evidence to provide, the UK is a lot longer and provides more time. Typically financial support is more limited and they can house people in shared centers outside of cities compared to the UK offerings. Even then, demand exceeds supply so they end up sleeping rough in camps which police dismantle (does anyone recall the Jungle in Calais).
In the UK, you can apply for ILR after 5 years of being a refugee and then naturalise a year after. This is on the condition you are good of character, no serious convictions and life in the UK test.
France is 5 years of regular residence too. They have the caveat though that you must demonstrate assimilation; spoken French , written French, French history, culture and values. Ontop of this they must show employment records, financial stability and a clean criminal record. It can take two years or so to get it. But it can be blocked on by local prefectures on subjective criteria.
On paper it looks similar, but in practice in France you’ll likely see delays , cultural and language hurdles along with subjective decisions made.
The year before it was 33%; it’ll take time to propagate as it becomes stricter but It’s pretty obvious why people would cross, if we continue to use the proverbial carrot compared the French stick; we can assume it will continue.
“Smashing the gangs” isn’t really going to do much; it’s akin to the war on drugs. If there are people who a product the market will find away.
I’m not saying the French system is superior to ours in anyway, I just don’t thing there is any easy answer at all to this and only difficult decisions forward. The reality is France is a lot tougher on migrants and they still have similar issues to us, no wonder they don’t stop the boats; why would they? Would we?
michalzxc on
You know what will smash the boat gangs? Buying every asylum seeker a flight ticket
Nobody will pay gangs if they will get a free flight
According_Pear_6272 on
It will continue to get worse until govt accepts that very unsavoury actions must be taken to stop it.
StoryEfficient7396 on
No shit Sherlock!
You scrapped the Rwanda deterrent morons!! Seriously Labour are both terribly naive and astoundingly stupid (and that’s being charitable).
Additional_Pickle_59 on
The navy patrolling the coast has got to be far cheaper than paying for them to live here for free.
Just asking for a catch and release program not breaking human rights. A processing centre at the coast, feed them a meal, give them a bed for the night, give them the correct visa/asylum documentation then send them back to France.
It’s more than the countries they’re from would ever give us.
SuperrVillain85 on
>Conservative shadow home secretary Chris Philp said “the Channel crisis is spiralling out of control” under Sir Keir’s watch.
Lol
ZX52 on
These people want to enter this country. Previously, they were jumping on the backs of lorries to hitch a ride across. That was clamped down on. Now they’re using the far more dangerous small boat method.
Clamping down on a specific mechanism of travel without addressing the motivation will not work. Either you’ve got to make it so that none of these people want to come here (without violating domestic or international law), or you’ve got to provide a safe alternative method to cross the channel. Anything else will guarantee this issue persists, albeit in a different form.
KernowKermit on
three options. 1. let them keep coming. 2. stop them coming. 3. make the UK such an unattractive place to live that they don’t want to come anyway.
we seem to be going for #3
Neberix on
Fucking hell, seriously? Why are half of the UK legacy media’s posting about fucking boats? Like they want to fuel closet racists and get reform in power? How on earth would that benefit them or anyone in this country?
Boats coming over aren’t the problem… Shitty fear mongering, Brexit fueling, fuckwit legacy media is.
Whilst they get to push the agenda, us seemingly dim Brits will sadly lap it up.
fuxvill on
Iran and Russia are sending as many insurgents over, before direct war kicks off.
CobblerSmall1891 on
What pisses me off is that UK is just letting itself get fucked like this.
ThatGuyMaulicious on
But Keir Starmer promise he’d smash the gangs what happened.
boringfantasy on
Starmer needs to take potentially brutal action otherwise Reform will win and our democracy is in peril.
Comrade-Hayley on
Maybe it’s got something to do with leaving the EU therefore France has no motivation to ensure the security of our borders?
RaleighsSoliloquy on
Do illegal immigrants actually get benefits? As someone who doesn’t get benefits I am naive – but I’d have thought you’d need a permanent address and/or a national insurance number?
GamblingDust on
Didn’t Australia have the same exact problem? And now it’s solved. Why can’t we copy their solution?
BroodLord1962 on
People of the UK have had enough. The Tories failed to deal with this problem and Labour are also failing. If there was a GE tomorrow, Reform would get in because they are the only party willing to leave the HRC so we can immediately deport anyone who arrives here
StarFlyXXL on
Maybe if there wasn’t so much war [(some of which that we have helped to fund)](https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9964/) we wouldn’t have so many people coming from wartorn counties. Doing stuff with the boats isn’t doing anything to stop the root of the problem, just redirecting the issue elsewhere
yammaniow726 on
Get the French, who are being paid by US, to do the job they are being paid and not do their usual retreating and reneging on their responsibilities!
28 commenti
But everyone assured me he was going to “smash the gangs” and that Labour were on top of it?
It’s a big problem and the solution will need patience to fix, otherwise we’ll end up with Skiver-in-Chief as PM with the party who claim the solution is simple and legal yet won’t publish their own legal advice.
The speed of light can’t be changed by us mere mortals.
Laws relating to asylum, benefits etc.? They can.
All this persists because Labour and Conservative governments want it too.
Imagine pretending a huge parliamentary majority – and the ability to introduce and conclude legislation on a single Saturday morning – isn’t enough.
Maybe prayer then?
Bombs land in iran. More Iranians cross channel. Simples
>Meeting on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Canada, Sir Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron agreed to “work closely” to tackle crossings, a No 10 spokesperson said.
Starmer need to sign a returns agreement with France and set up a processing center in Calais ASAP. If people can apply for asylum from France, they won’t cross the channel. If they know that they will be returned to France, they won’t cross either. The reason practically no one crossed the channel before Brexit is because of this returns agreement. Without it Starmer won’t solve the problem.
Whilst people believe that they can have a easier time in the UK they will keep coming, no deal the UK strikes with France will stop this.
The only way to stop this is to implement changes and rules that make coming to the UK not worth risking your life over.
I’ve said it before and I will say it again, we need to have Migrant Centres where anybody arriving illegal by any methods are sent to and can not leave until their application has been processed and accepted.
Everyone else will be sent back.
Whilst at the centre all their medical needs will be seen to and they will have a safe warm place to sleep and eat.
They don’t need anything else.
This will stop the majority of economic migrants as they will not be able to earn any money for months and they can’t just disappear.
It will have a massive impact on people taking advantage of those here illegally, Factories, Car Washers, Fast Food Take Aways, Delivery Drivers Uber Drivers etc..
This will also help reduce the strain on local councils and public services.
It is a win, win situation and also done in quite a few European Countries.
From a purely cynical point of view it is a garratueed vote winner and will pretty much put an end to Reform.
Labour desperately need to grow a set of balls and announce the building of Migrant Centres.
Arrest those landing not at a port.
Detain them in designated facilities (not hotels), such as cordoned inside military areas, within fences, under guard, provided with shelter (tents), running water, hygiene facilities, and provisions (out of date combat rations).
Bring the home office staff there, so they can process the asylum claims in situ.
If granted asylum let out, even provide a coach to a Jobcentre that’s struggling to recruit.
If not granted asylum, deport, and record for immediate deportation should they attempt re-entry.
I won’t even charge the £25m consulting fee that Deloitte would have to produce this outline.
If we end up at war with someone, are we still going to allow potential enemies in via this route?
Now Iran is going to be bombed to smithereens, it will be 10 times worse, cheers Donald.
An interesting thing is typically the differences on how the French process goes compared to the UK.
This is going to be a wall of text but I’m just comparing the two and you’ll see why it’s rising.
For example, France demand more documentation early on in the process and when asked for documents and evidence to provide, the UK is a lot longer and provides more time. Typically financial support is more limited and they can house people in shared centers outside of cities compared to the UK offerings. Even then, demand exceeds supply so they end up sleeping rough in camps which police dismantle (does anyone recall the Jungle in Calais).
In the UK, you can apply for ILR after 5 years of being a refugee and then naturalise a year after. This is on the condition you are good of character, no serious convictions and life in the UK test.
France is 5 years of regular residence too. They have the caveat though that you must demonstrate assimilation; spoken French , written French, French history, culture and values. Ontop of this they must show employment records, financial stability and a clean criminal record. It can take two years or so to get it. But it can be blocked on by local prefectures on subjective criteria.
On paper it looks similar, but in practice in France you’ll likely see delays , cultural and language hurdles along with subjective decisions made.
Let’s not just forget the rejection rates
France: 60-70%
https://ecre.org/aida-country-report-on-france-2023-update/
UK: 40-50% (in 2023, which was the above source for France it was 33%)
https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/immigration-system-statistics-year-ending-december-2024/how-many-people-are-granted-asylum-in-the-uk
The year before it was 33%; it’ll take time to propagate as it becomes stricter but It’s pretty obvious why people would cross, if we continue to use the proverbial carrot compared the French stick; we can assume it will continue.
“Smashing the gangs” isn’t really going to do much; it’s akin to the war on drugs. If there are people who a product the market will find away.
I’m not saying the French system is superior to ours in anyway, I just don’t thing there is any easy answer at all to this and only difficult decisions forward. The reality is France is a lot tougher on migrants and they still have similar issues to us, no wonder they don’t stop the boats; why would they? Would we?
You know what will smash the boat gangs? Buying every asylum seeker a flight ticket
Nobody will pay gangs if they will get a free flight
It will continue to get worse until govt accepts that very unsavoury actions must be taken to stop it.
No shit Sherlock!
You scrapped the Rwanda deterrent morons!! Seriously Labour are both terribly naive and astoundingly stupid (and that’s being charitable).
The navy patrolling the coast has got to be far cheaper than paying for them to live here for free.
Just asking for a catch and release program not breaking human rights. A processing centre at the coast, feed them a meal, give them a bed for the night, give them the correct visa/asylum documentation then send them back to France.
It’s more than the countries they’re from would ever give us.
>Conservative shadow home secretary Chris Philp said “the Channel crisis is spiralling out of control” under Sir Keir’s watch.
Lol
These people want to enter this country. Previously, they were jumping on the backs of lorries to hitch a ride across. That was clamped down on. Now they’re using the far more dangerous small boat method.
Clamping down on a specific mechanism of travel without addressing the motivation will not work. Either you’ve got to make it so that none of these people want to come here (without violating domestic or international law), or you’ve got to provide a safe alternative method to cross the channel. Anything else will guarantee this issue persists, albeit in a different form.
three options. 1. let them keep coming. 2. stop them coming. 3. make the UK such an unattractive place to live that they don’t want to come anyway.
we seem to be going for #3
Fucking hell, seriously? Why are half of the UK legacy media’s posting about fucking boats? Like they want to fuel closet racists and get reform in power? How on earth would that benefit them or anyone in this country?
Boats coming over aren’t the problem… Shitty fear mongering, Brexit fueling, fuckwit legacy media is.
Whilst they get to push the agenda, us seemingly dim Brits will sadly lap it up.
Iran and Russia are sending as many insurgents over, before direct war kicks off.
What pisses me off is that UK is just letting itself get fucked like this.
But Keir Starmer promise he’d smash the gangs what happened.
Starmer needs to take potentially brutal action otherwise Reform will win and our democracy is in peril.
Maybe it’s got something to do with leaving the EU therefore France has no motivation to ensure the security of our borders?
Do illegal immigrants actually get benefits? As someone who doesn’t get benefits I am naive – but I’d have thought you’d need a permanent address and/or a national insurance number?
Didn’t Australia have the same exact problem? And now it’s solved. Why can’t we copy their solution?
People of the UK have had enough. The Tories failed to deal with this problem and Labour are also failing. If there was a GE tomorrow, Reform would get in because they are the only party willing to leave the HRC so we can immediately deport anyone who arrives here
Maybe if there wasn’t so much war [(some of which that we have helped to fund)](https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9964/) we wouldn’t have so many people coming from wartorn counties. Doing stuff with the boats isn’t doing anything to stop the root of the problem, just redirecting the issue elsewhere
Get the French, who are being paid by US, to do the job they are being paid and not do their usual retreating and reneging on their responsibilities!