UK Public Service TV “Endangerd” nell’era di YouTube, afferma Ofcom
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/jul/21/uk-public-service-tv-youtube-ofcom-video
di printial
UK Public Service TV “Endangerd” nell’era di YouTube, afferma Ofcom
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/jul/21/uk-public-service-tv-youtube-ofcom-video
di printial
38 commenti
BBC should have been rebuilt from the ground up after jimmy savile
This Saturday, BBC’s line-up consisted of a 3 year old repeat of Michael McIntyre’s The Wheel, a 1 year old episode of Pointless Celebrities, a 3 year old episode of Blankety Blank, a 2 year old episode of The Weakest Link.
I wonder why people are moving away.
Adapt or die, it’s one of nature’s few constants.
But for some reason, a lot of people with the power to change things seem to think that doing the same thing over and over or regressing into the past are the only two solutions. This extends a lot further than the BBC.
Good? Times have changed and the young generations do not consumer media how we once did.
I wasn’t bought up sat around the radio in the living room, TV needs to realise it will no longer be the primary breadwinner and falls into a secondary service just like radio did.
Alot of good YouTube creators produce better content than traditional TV networks
Public broadcasting lost the battle when it started catering for cheap TV. Victoria Derbyshire is probably a great journo, but Auntie has ruined Newsnight by turning it into a debate platform pitting informed views against fringe opinion.
As soon as Beeb moved into this realm it was done for as the private sector do it cheaper and with less regulation tying them down – see Gbeebies.
YouTube didn’t kill the Beeb – it’s committing suicide.
When I was young (35 years ago) there were so many good programmes on TV. Great documentaries, comedy which was actually funny, top of the pops, gameshows… lots of really good stuff. Nature programmes, even the kids TV was great!
Now it’s all dumbed – down shite. Comedy you just don’t get. Documentaries which make everything into a story.
Repeats all the time.
No wonder people are looking for a change!
Go back to making good programmes and TV might see a resurgence. But I won’t hold my breath!
The only thing BBC is good for these days is gritty dramas and football coverage. Can’t remember the last time I sat down and put the TV on and saw something on channel 1 or 2 that I actually wanted to watch. It’s all just old gameshows or other crap. Scrap the licence fee.
The BBC is one of our greatest institutions. It informs and entertains for a fraction of the cost of sky or fibre. The radio arm is diverse, and the world service is respected across the globe. If it is ever pulled, then this country will be all the poorer for it.
Ofcom is a dinosaur too, well past its sell by date.
Adapt or die.. we’ve had a TV license for a while justified by kids shows that have some values or education, but it’s too much to then not get the same back as an adult. It’s jot even YouTube, it’s netflix, prime, now, there’s tonnes of better shit on there
What incentive does the BBC as an institution have to keep up with the times?
It’s not like they have to please the audience to keep their lights on, just do enough so the government doesn’t cut your budgets. They are doing exactly that.
I do still think the BBC in general as a whole package is pretty great. Services like BBC News (which is a monster in of itself), live sport, Radio, Weather, Food, documentaries, kids tv/education, the occasional drama still have their place in my opinion, and would be missed if they went. Also the local news is really good compared to a lot of the ad drowned local papers in most towns and counties.
All of those things at once I’d argue are genuinely worth the £14 a month which equates to about what you pay for Netflix or Disney +.
But it absolutely needs to shift away from live broadcast scheduled TV and towards an “app package” or “ service package” that includes everything the BBC has to offer. Or at the very least a hybrid of that and the tv license system. Britbox in my view was a good try, but a bit half baked. People also just don’t like that it’s an opt out, rather than opt in sort of situation for the TV license. But regardless, the whole interface of the TV license page is incredibly adversarial and very detached from telling you what the BBC actually offers.
They need to completely re-brand and re-sell what I actually think is quite a good package. Pointing out that you actually get quite a lot for the subscription fee. Most of which you can access for completely free at the moment, with the BBC really only stressing that you’re paying for the live broadcast and iPlayer part.
That said, maybe once you start putting up the paywalls on a lot of its services, you’d find most people just aren’t interested in any of it 90% of the year. Hence why they’ve probably resisted doing it.
So it’s repeats, Mrs brown’s boys, sport or news
Vs
Specific YouTubers who create content weekly to daily about my exact hobbies and interests that the BBC could never make a programme about
I think there are 5? Ish shows I’ve gone back to iPlayer for 2 are now canceled or over what am I supposed to do sit and watch anything with the little time I get
If anything I watch old BBC shows on YouTube like noels house party for little nostalgia boosts
To watch you need to pay tv license. I don’t pay as there are better forms of entertainment available for the price. I might watch a bit if there wasnt a cost involved. Scrapping the fee is a good starting point.
Kids don’t watch TV anymore. It’s either, Roblox or YouTube for them these days. Television is dead.
I’d happily see all broadcast TV moved online or disappear altogether as long as Youtube, Netflix and the other streaming continued.
Our Broadcast media have been totally behind all the technical innovation that are going on. They only cater for old people and the lowest common denominator.
Good riddance and take the TV licence fee with you.
Yes, and it needs to adapt. This is how capitalism works
Hard to really have sympathy. Between the enablement of pedophiles and sexual predators, blacklisting whistleblowers and most recently not allowing a documentary on Gaza, I get the feeling it’s a pretty evil institution that needs to die or be completely overhauled anyway.
Haven’t owned a TV or watched the BBC for years, no need these days.
YouTube Premium is worth every penny. I almost couldn’t fathom paying for it back when it launched, now it feels like I couldn’t live without it. We got hooked on some small travel content creators, who made a trip to some mundane town an entire half hour video, and it was genuinely entertaining. Channel 4 have also started uploading to YouTube which is great because YT is a far better platform than what BBC etc use.
Because the BBC haven’t made anything good in forever, it’s all crappy crime dramas and naff gameshows.
What’s the reason that we ‘must have’ public service TV?
Well yeah… nothing worth watching on BBC except a nature doc which ends up on Netflix anyway. Make great shows and people will come
Well, the saving the BBC could do is cut funding from all of its News and weather on TV, Radio and Website consolidating it if required (it does not need a different news presenter and weather person for every station and locality). Oh and cut up that contract with Capita and their goons that harass non-licence payers.
And put that money towards making some more diverse content that’s not soaps and game shows.
But what would I know? I’m subscribed to Mr Hewes on youtube fooling about with tanks and Jim Bowen’s old Bentley. Most people probably wouldn’t be interested in that. Oh, and EmeliaHartford, erm, just because.
Good. It’s full of crap now, anyway. Serve it’s death knell ASAP. please.
Most of the BBC is slop for boomers or news curated and presented with an English establishment bias (TM). The only reason it still exists is because of some exclusive content like sports, but mostly because it caters to people who haven’t adapted to using the internet as their main source of home entertainment.
Its TV side will die with the last boomers, one way or another.
They should focus on global revenue via an enticing iPlayer subscription model, instead of looking for excuses to put all their hope in their special revenue model via taxation in the UK, with probably an arrangement with the government to keep it in public ownership and to use it as a platform during emergency broadcasts.
any company that provides a service people dont want, at a price point they wont pay isnt going to survive, its simple economics. The BBC is not exempt from that just because it sends people scary looking letters
So…getting the reasons in early to change from ‘TV Licence’ to ‘Internet Licence’ I see…. /s
– BBC budget cut by 25% since 2010 so not surprising there’s less quality content. Standard right-wing attack on public institutions: cut funding so it can’t function properly, use the fact that it’s not functioning properly to justify further cuts.
– 90% of adults use at least one BBC service each week (The BBC isn’t just broadcast TV) and it only drops to 85% if you only consider 16-34s.
– Commercial stations can’t afford to produce public interest content; ITV said they made a massive loss on Mr Bates vs The Post Office.
– Netflix and YouTube aren’t sending war reporters to Ukraine so you’re not comparing apples with apples.
– The World Service is massive source of soft power for the UK.
– The cost of administering the licence fee is less than the overhead of marketing/billing/etc. for a subscription service or the overheads of running an advertising department, so ultimately you’d be getting less for your money.
– Generally staff at the BBC are happier to accept a lower salary to be in public service, look at so cheaper for the BBC to produce most shows. Does anyone think Amazon paid less for The Grand Tour than the BBC spent on Top Gear? Even if you never watched The Grand Tour you still paid for it every time you shopped on Amazon or bought a product that advertises on Amazon, so abolishing the BBC is still lumping more cost onto you, you just don’t see it.
Tv is just regurgitated crap filled with adverts, why would I watch it
Yeah it’s because you’ve been showing a revolving door of property shows, auction shows, cooking shows and tea time quiz shows for the last twenty plus years. Your content sucks!
Maybe Ofcom should have done it’s job, and we wouldn’t have ended up in this mess!
TV is mostly made up of of dumb reality shows and mind numbing game shows and I would rather watch Youtube. at least then I can choose what type I want to watch
My kids are 11 and 6, neither of them have ever watched broadcast TV. Not at home anyway. They’ll watch TV from a couple of the normal streamers, a couple of on-demand services from abroad, and a little YouTube. I cancelled the TV Licence in 2015 when I realised I myself hadn’t watched broadcast TV in over a year.
I don’t think they even conceive of waiting until a particular time of day to watch a TV program.
Make something that isn’t just “diverse cast in a modern setting does something modern” or “Doctor Who smashes the norms” and maybe the BBC would be a relevant producer of television. That’s the sort of stuff Youtube cannot replace but when you compare the BBC’s output to other streaming services then it’s embarassing.
And they have thoroughly murdered their golden goose IPs in favour of some internal BBC-approved ideology that has not translated to success.
The BBC also did used to have good niche content, stuff like Screenwipe etc. and Youtube has replaced that entirely.
The BBC needs to drop the mission to ‘entertain’, and it would be alot more relwvant, and a hell.of alot smaller.
Keep the news, and maybe at a push, BBC One.
I used to adore the BBC, now I hate it. Not willingly watched it in over 20 years.