“The excess amount, which Barclays said was based on people who already hold more than six months’ income in cash, underscores the challenge facing the government as it tries to funnel more money into investments.”
I presume this is going to mainly be retired people and folk saving for deposits etc who aren’t going to be wanting to risk the cash on short term fluctuations in the stock market.
beach-chicken10 on
UK government froths at the mouth as to how they can further tax this
boycecodd on
I find the use of the term “excess cash” weird.
Even if you’re young, there are many reasons why you might want to keep your savings in cash beyond just your emergency fund. If you’re saving up for a house deposit, home renovation, wedding or other big thing then you’re unlikely to want to risk that money on investments that might go down.
I do think though that public education of some kind would be beneficial regarding investments. A lot of people think it involves individual stock picking (I’ve been asked what stocks I recommend when I mention that I’ve got money in stocks and shares) and that’s understandably offputting. No investment is risk free by any means but it’s a lot less risky to chuck your money into an index tracker than try and guess which individual companies will do well.
As someone getting older, who has worked hard and saved, got no kids and have seen the state of social care and state pension ages, I’m calling it a survival fund, thanks.
We should absolutely encourage people to save so that they can live at a decent standard when they are older without resorting to the state. Using terms like “excess cash” doesn’t seem helpful.
Educational-Cry-1707 on
This is an average of roughly £10k/person in the UK, and even if you discount children (although older kids may have a few hundred to count towards this) it’s a perfectly reasonable amount of money to have in cash to cover unexpected expenses, periods of unemployment or even just saving up towards something. The Cash ISA allowance is double that.
crappy_ninja on
That’s less than the combined worth of the 2 richest people.
BlunanNation on
God forbid anyone in this country have more then 20 pounds to their name.
This sort of bullshit is the reason we are in this mess of no growth and shit productivity.
spaceninjaking on
The hype I don’t get around this is that what is most likely to happen off of a big push for moving cash savings to investments is that people will instead invest in global and specifically US equity/index funds, so whilst the average uk citizen may end up with more value in assets, actual uk companies won’t see much of a benefit besides the platforms and financial advisers, as nobody will be investing in them.
BobBobBobBobBobDave on
Savings aren’t excess cash.
They have savings, so that one day they might be able to retire, get on the property ladder, make home improvements, etc.
It isnt “excess” in any sense.
SingleFatherOf4 on
Like basically every other issue with this country, the Government needs some radical housing reform. They can keep lowering interest rates & try telling everyone how we need to spend to save the economy, but every young person is saving for a house & they’re going to keep living frugally & saving until they can get one. Once they have a house/aren’t paying all their income on rent, then they’ll have true excess to spend.
Instead they’ve always focussed on concentrating all the wealth into the older generations who already have everything they need & don’t spend at all
xcoatsyx on
The gov’t desperately wants this invested but is ignoring the demographics and importance of cash in various circumstances.
DiligentCockroach700 on
I have some savings but no way would I call it “excess cash”.
fresh2112 on
Excess? 6 monthly cycles of redundancy, 5%+ mortgage, on the ladder late at 38 and largely due to a bereavement kicking me enough money for a deposit.
Fuck all excess about it
greenpowerman99 on
Is that all, less than £9000 per person on average? Scary stuff…
SmashedWorm64 on
I understand that it makes sense for more people to be invested than holding cash savings… but the country lacks the financial education to do so.
If people invested without understanding what they were investing in, it would be a disaster.
16 commenti
“The excess amount, which Barclays said was based on people who already hold more than six months’ income in cash, underscores the challenge facing the government as it tries to funnel more money into investments.”
I presume this is going to mainly be retired people and folk saving for deposits etc who aren’t going to be wanting to risk the cash on short term fluctuations in the stock market.
UK government froths at the mouth as to how they can further tax this
I find the use of the term “excess cash” weird.
Even if you’re young, there are many reasons why you might want to keep your savings in cash beyond just your emergency fund. If you’re saving up for a house deposit, home renovation, wedding or other big thing then you’re unlikely to want to risk that money on investments that might go down.
I do think though that public education of some kind would be beneficial regarding investments. A lot of people think it involves individual stock picking (I’ve been asked what stocks I recommend when I mention that I’ve got money in stocks and shares) and that’s understandably offputting. No investment is risk free by any means but it’s a lot less risky to chuck your money into an index tracker than try and guess which individual companies will do well.
Non-paywall article link
https://archive.is/2025.09.12-051025/https://www.ft.com/content/37af2ffd-0a82-4150-b89c-3d5390ea9062
As someone getting older, who has worked hard and saved, got no kids and have seen the state of social care and state pension ages, I’m calling it a survival fund, thanks.
We should absolutely encourage people to save so that they can live at a decent standard when they are older without resorting to the state. Using terms like “excess cash” doesn’t seem helpful.
This is an average of roughly £10k/person in the UK, and even if you discount children (although older kids may have a few hundred to count towards this) it’s a perfectly reasonable amount of money to have in cash to cover unexpected expenses, periods of unemployment or even just saving up towards something. The Cash ISA allowance is double that.
That’s less than the combined worth of the 2 richest people.
God forbid anyone in this country have more then 20 pounds to their name.
This sort of bullshit is the reason we are in this mess of no growth and shit productivity.
The hype I don’t get around this is that what is most likely to happen off of a big push for moving cash savings to investments is that people will instead invest in global and specifically US equity/index funds, so whilst the average uk citizen may end up with more value in assets, actual uk companies won’t see much of a benefit besides the platforms and financial advisers, as nobody will be investing in them.
Savings aren’t excess cash.
They have savings, so that one day they might be able to retire, get on the property ladder, make home improvements, etc.
It isnt “excess” in any sense.
Like basically every other issue with this country, the Government needs some radical housing reform. They can keep lowering interest rates & try telling everyone how we need to spend to save the economy, but every young person is saving for a house & they’re going to keep living frugally & saving until they can get one. Once they have a house/aren’t paying all their income on rent, then they’ll have true excess to spend.
Instead they’ve always focussed on concentrating all the wealth into the older generations who already have everything they need & don’t spend at all
The gov’t desperately wants this invested but is ignoring the demographics and importance of cash in various circumstances.
I have some savings but no way would I call it “excess cash”.
Excess? 6 monthly cycles of redundancy, 5%+ mortgage, on the ladder late at 38 and largely due to a bereavement kicking me enough money for a deposit.
Fuck all excess about it
Is that all, less than £9000 per person on average? Scary stuff…
I understand that it makes sense for more people to be invested than holding cash savings… but the country lacks the financial education to do so.
If people invested without understanding what they were investing in, it would be a disaster.