Translation: The Kingdom of the Netherlands could sue Slovakia before the European Court of Justice over the recent amendment to the Slovak Constitution.
This follows from a resolution adopted by the Dutch Parliament on October 16. In the resolution, the Parliament refers to Article 259 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which states that “a Member State which considers that another Member State has failed to fulfill an obligation under the Treaties may bring the matter before the Court of Justice of the European Union.”
A group of MPs mention in the resolution the Slovak constitutional amendment that placed national law above EU law and restricted the rights of LGBTI people.
“We convinced the Dutch Parliament to support our proposal, and we hope that the Court will stop Fico’s violations of LGBT rights and our shared European freedoms,” said Laurens Dassen, the proposal’s sponsor and an MP for the liberal Volt party, in a statement to the Slovak daily SME.
“Every European should have the freedom to be who they want to be. But populists are undermining our European freedoms, and the old parties no longer have the courage to stand up for a common European future,” he added.
The Dutch Parliament itself cannot sue Slovakia, but through the resolution it calls on the government to file such a lawsuit.
The Treaty on the Functioning of the EU stipulates that before submitting a lawsuit, a Member State must first bring the complaint before the European Commission, which is to hear the positions of both states in an adversarial procedure.
berejser on
I don’t know how strong their legal case is, but it is a really bad amendment and Slovaks would be better off if they repeal it.
mrlinkwii on
why tho , the EU hasnt passed any laws on LGBTI , their is no EU level law in terms of LGBTI , ( from what i remember poland vetod any discussion of it ) the dutch has no legal ground to sue if they claim it breaks a treaty
honestly its none of the dutch parliments business what other countries do to their constitutions
b00c on
It’s a win-win for ficokokot. bad EU because they want Slovaks to be gay. So we make own rules. Slovakia gets sued, loses, has to pay and change constitution. Now EU bad again because they force us to not hate gays.
4 commenti
Translation: The Kingdom of the Netherlands could sue Slovakia before the European Court of Justice over the recent amendment to the Slovak Constitution.
This follows from a resolution adopted by the Dutch Parliament on October 16. In the resolution, the Parliament refers to Article 259 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which states that “a Member State which considers that another Member State has failed to fulfill an obligation under the Treaties may bring the matter before the Court of Justice of the European Union.”
A group of MPs mention in the resolution the Slovak constitutional amendment that placed national law above EU law and restricted the rights of LGBTI people.
“We convinced the Dutch Parliament to support our proposal, and we hope that the Court will stop Fico’s violations of LGBT rights and our shared European freedoms,” said Laurens Dassen, the proposal’s sponsor and an MP for the liberal Volt party, in a statement to the Slovak daily SME.
“Every European should have the freedom to be who they want to be. But populists are undermining our European freedoms, and the old parties no longer have the courage to stand up for a common European future,” he added.
The Dutch Parliament itself cannot sue Slovakia, but through the resolution it calls on the government to file such a lawsuit.
The Treaty on the Functioning of the EU stipulates that before submitting a lawsuit, a Member State must first bring the complaint before the European Commission, which is to hear the positions of both states in an adversarial procedure.
I don’t know how strong their legal case is, but it is a really bad amendment and Slovaks would be better off if they repeal it.
why tho , the EU hasnt passed any laws on LGBTI , their is no EU level law in terms of LGBTI , ( from what i remember poland vetod any discussion of it ) the dutch has no legal ground to sue if they claim it breaks a treaty
honestly its none of the dutch parliments business what other countries do to their constitutions
It’s a win-win for ficokokot. bad EU because they want Slovaks to be gay. So we make own rules. Slovakia gets sued, loses, has to pay and change constitution. Now EU bad again because they force us to not hate gays.