Close Menu
    Regno Unito

    “Un mucchio di scrocconi”: crescente pressione da parte del Regno Unito sull’Irlanda affinché investa nella difesa

    Share.
    View 24 Comments

    24 commenti

    1. SableSnail on

      They didn’t even go to war against literal Hitler, I wouldn’t expect it to be any different with Putin.

    2. slagmunch on

      Freeloaders is a bit harsh, but Ireland does need to pull their socks up and become an equal partner in the defence of our islands and not just a recipient.

      It was understandable when they were a poor and newly independent country, but they are now quite wealthy and have been independent for over 100 years.

    3. Apprehensive_Home963 on

      They really need too and its right they are being pressured. We live in a new and dangerous time and everybody has to pull thier weight in and not expect its somebody elses burdern to bare.

    4. Embarrassed-File3335 on

      I don’t mind them “freeloading” on defense commitments.

      I mind UK taxpayers paying for defense of an impressive amount of tax havens. Like following:
      British Overseas Territories: British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Bermuda, Anguilla, Gibraltar, Turks and Caicos Islands, and Montserrat.
      Crown Dependencies: Jersey, Guernsey, and the Isle of Man.

      And also Ireland.

    6. SarcasticallyCandour on

      If Putin’s conscripts arrive by rubber dinghy, will they be put up in a hotel for free?

    7. LopsidedLegs on

      I wonder if Austria is going to come under similar pressure?

    8. DoNotCommentAgain on

      Their population still hasn’t recovered from the genocide we did to them, I’m all for flinging mud at European nations who don’t pay their fair share in defence but I’m not sure we should start with Ireland.

      There’s plenty of wealthy countries out there who have benefited from our help, who then immediately turned round and gave us the finger. Our allies are not really allies when they don’t bring anything to the table.

      The UK and US are pretty much the only countries in NATO that have consistently met their spending obligations. We should be expecting far more from these nations instead of punching down on Ireland. It’s shameful how these wealthy countries we helped rebuild have betrayed the alliance.

    9. Nearby_Potato4001 on

      A bunch of freeloaders is something that someone without any historical context would say. It very much suited Britain to have the RAF intercept Russians spy-planes in the cold war brinksmanship over Irish airspace rather that British airspace. It was a mutual Anglo-Irish agreement that spanned many Westminster governments both Conservative and Labour. Those decision makers in Whitehall knew then, know now and will know in the future what serves British defence strategy much better than a bunch of freeloading hacks.

    11. ash_ninetyone on

      Tbh Ireland kinda requires folk to go through the UK or around it to get to it.

      And Ireland also knows that the UK wouldn’t able to stand idly by if an invasion lands on it’s shores, especially if it is someone that threatens us.

      Collective defence is in mutual interest here, regardless of our past animosity.

      This isn’t like the US calling Europe freeloaders. Like if, *if*, the RoI does end up falling to an unfriendly country, we’re not in a position to just leave them at it as a “we told you so”

      We’d be forced to intervene for our sakes.

      Doesn’t necessarily stop us thinking they should pay more. But there is that reality about this

    13. trmetroidmaniac on

      The Irish can tell the British state where to shove it.

    14. ChickenPijja on

      Isn’t Ireland famously an independent nation with regards to defence & military? Especially being out of NATO I’m not expecting them to spend massively on defence.

      If the shit hits the fan then expect them to be the first in line to complain and want defending though

    15. Future-Atmosphere-40 on

      Rangers are top class special forces, beating both Delta force and SAS.

      Be good at what you do.

    16. AMoonMonkey on

      If they suddenly came under attack by a foreign country, I bet we’d be the first country they’d expect to help defend them.

    17. Chargerado on

      At the end of the day it’s up to the EU to sort that out as it’s one of their members.

    18. Intergalatic_Baker on

      Look, I’m not saying they should be rebuilding a military capacity like what the Polish or British or Germans or French are building up, but they could do with some capability for ASW, since they’re going to have to defend their subsea cables, so a Type-26 or 3 would do for them, plus the Helicopters.

      Then their air defence, I’m not saying they need F-35’s but a squadron of Typhoons maybe 2 squadrons to protect the skies. If they don’t want the planes, then air defence missile batteries and radar stations.

      Their buying and use of this equipment wouldn’t need them to shrug off their neutrality.
      Indeed, the kit examples, like the Typhoons are capable jets and European and already used across Europe, with the British able to help maintenance and training in the early days and and wider integration European trading partners.

      The Type-26s, that’s turning into an export success and is going to be operating in the area it was built for, so them signing on to it would make sense, even if they chose not to require all the VLS, but they could have the later option to.

      TLDR: Ireland just needs to buy some kit that works and their neighbours use, no, they don’t need stealth fighters. Yes, they need Anti-Submarine Warfare Frigates, no, they don’t need a balls to the walls VLS equipped one either (But it would be handy for them on the Air Defence role).

    19. amanset on

      Schrödinger’s Irishman.

      Simultaneously hating the British Army and relying on the British Army for defence.

    20. judochop1 on

      Too right, the Atlantic on their side is wide open and puts UK and Europe at a vulnerability, best the Irish fill what gaps there are and not leave their allies over stretched

    21. CatchRevolutionary65 on

      “I know, let’s voluntarily give any leverage power we have”

    22. CongealedBeanKingdom on

      Surely the UK would want to defend the 6 counties that it clearly cares so much about. Do they count for nothing?

    23. Latespoon on

      Let’s say Ireland starts spending hard on defence. They are a small country, wealthy on paper but not in the bank. They might muster 1-2 Typhoon squadrons and a submarine hunter. Maybe some naval frigates.

      What are we going to save exactly?

      Are the RAF going to retire some of our typhoons because now Ireland has some? Are the Royal Navy going to stop patrolling the North Atlantic?

      Are we going to entrust the security of the British Isles to our still very underpowered neighbour that is 1/10th our size?

      I very much doubt we would save anything significant at all.

    24. I_Call_Bullshit_____ on

      Ahhhh, so refreshing to see r/Europe and r/unitedkingdom finally acknowledge and empathize with the US’s position on NATO! /s

      “Noooo this is difffeeerrreeennttt….”

      It’s the same guys, just because Trump’s a monster and loser of the highest order doesn’t mean he was wrong about Europe generally freeloading off the US’s security umbrella since the Wall fell. It turns out that a broken clock really is right twice a day.

      It (the freeloading) was wrong. As is Ireland (and Spain)’s freeloading off the rest of the continent. It’s wrong.

      Now, let your downvotes wash over me like a sweet summer rain…[Ryan Gosling from The Big Short said it all already](https://youtube.com/shorts/y0H9LIpVuT4?si=bCqO8zXRwQGaHJb2)

    Leave A Reply