Jonathan Turley: Dopo Orban, l’UE rappresenta una minaccia ancora maggiore per la sovranità degli Stati Uniti

https://thehill.com/opinion/international/5837247-post-orban-the-eu-hopes-to-destroy-the-national-identity-sovereignty/amp/

di Crossstoney

50 commenti

  1. Naive_Class7033 on

    The EU poses a threat to US sovereignty? Ummm is that a typo?

  2. PianistHairy9431 on

    we were allies for so many years and no one complained, and now all of a sudden EU is a big problem. Sure, whatever you say. Classic right-wing divide and conquer politics.

  3. Skolloc753 on

    > In [my book] “Rage and the Republic,” I discuss the dangers posed to the American republic this century by the rise of global governance systems like the EU.

    Here is it, the money grift. *”Please buy my book”*.

    > *The book explores how globalists planned to gradually get nations to yield their authority to the EU *

    You mean the nations who willingly wants to joint he EU, has to uphold high democratic and human rights standards, can leave anytime and where in the very first treaties for the EU the demand for a more and more closer cooperation is very publicly tated … *for decades now*? That EU?

    > Orban was controversial for his ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin and his lack of support for Ukraine. He was also accused of authoritarianism and corruption.

    Good Sir, you are missing a few important points: He was not accused of, he was actively participating it, by reworking the constitution, the courts, the media control. Furthermore his government actively workd in secret against the EU, including taking direct orders from Moscow and sharing confidential strategy meetings with Russian intelligence. Not to mention that was was not only lacking in support for Ukraine, he actively opposed any help for Ukraine, including the latest 90bn EUR bill.

    > If the American Republic is to survive another 250 years, it must preserve key rights that the EU has been systematically destroying in Europe — freedom of speech, division of powers and political accountability of decision-makers.

    Who again is suing the Atlantic for 250 million USD for calling the FBI director drunk?

    SYL

  4. nolnogax on

    Man, the stuff that guy had been smoking must have been strong

  5. Slephnirr on

    At this point we should just stop posting any news outlet that clearly is not living in the same reality as the rest of the world. Especially *some* news outlets from the US do live in their own world and are hardly distinguishable from satire site.
    Any kind of rational discussion is totally unfruitful if you argue based on fiction.

  6. just focus on the Pacific theater as you promised, thank you very much.

  7. ReadyAndSalted on

    This is a pretty incredible article, it reads like a parody that an EU citizen would write to make fun of Americans. I mean are they *seriously* going to lecture us about political accountability whilst they continue to do nothing about Epstein, despite being the epicentre of the whole thing? It reads like we’re being framed as the red scare 2.0.

  8. Ok-Award-9542 on

    This guy should fuck off and pay more attention to the problems in his own country.

  9. Italiandude2022 on

    Spent a couple minutes to read this bullshit article. It all boils down to the usual “EU globalists bad, they want to dismantle national states and establish a Bruxelles dictatorship”, and that Peter Magyar will bend down to Von Der Leyen and sell Hungary to the EU so that she can get rid of veto rights. All while praising the “American Republic” that stands against this unprecedent threat of this globalist dictatorship that wants to cancel all american freedoms.

    Also, as usual, he cried about EU regulations against tech companies.

    I get that this is an opinion article, but its a shitty opinion and no one asked for it, cause it has been repeated over and over for years now by populist far-right parties. They could try to yell about other things but they always choose to yap about the same things: EU bad, regulations bad, globalist elites controll us.

  10. shatureg on

    The enitre article is projection. Consider this:

    >That is why, I believe, the EU is inherently unstable and likely to ultimately collapse.

    >The EU has worked very hard to dismantle national sovereignty and identity in its member states. Historically, such collapses have been followed by different forms of tyranny.

    >Whatever comes next — and I could be wrong in my pessimism about the EU — the U.S. must take seriously the threat that this global governance system poses to our own values and sovereignty.

    In reality, it’s the United States that is both administering a global governance system (its informal American empire) and also edging closer to collapse with every consecutive administration. And it is the EU that needs to take the threat of the rising American tyranny more serious than it currently does.

  11. serpenta on

    >If the American Republic is to survive another 250 years, it must preserve key rights that the EU has been systematically destroying in Europe — freedom of speech, division of powers and political accountability of decision-makers.

    BRUV! Stop projecting, it’s hurting my eyes.

  12. EINFACH_NUR_DAEMLICH on

    can we please ban this shitty propaganda website?

  13. TailleventCH on

    It’s interesting to (try to) follow the reasoning.It starts with an interesting question on the relationship between a form of supranational authority and “traditional” states. Unsurprisingly, the answer totally lacks nuance but it could make for an interesting talking point.Then, without too much care for transition, it switches to how it could threaten US sovereignty by wishing to submit it to a “global governance system”.

    At that stage, many readers may think it’s an allusion to larger private economical powers but it soon appears that US corporations are also victims of that “unaccountable” power.

    It then turns back to EU which is apparently trying to destroy national identities. (I really someone can explain me how sharing some technical laws and a general sense of the rule of law can achieve that.)

    Finally, it obviously ends on a praise of the rights saved by the US revolution, that were (not surprisingly) given by God and “not by a government”

    I’m happy I don’t have to give this a grade in my argumentation class.

  14. a-nn-on_ on

    How is the EU blocking his freedom of speech?

    Does he mean this?

    > The European Union designed the 2023 Digital Services Act to force Google, Facebook, Twitter, Telegram, and other digital platforms to combat disinformation, online extremism, and outright scams.

    “Oh the EU won’t let me spread disinformation and fake news so I can manipulate the masses, sob sob”

  15. Capital_Resident_872 on

    The Kingdom of Denmark would like to have a word

  16. GeneraalSorryPardon on

    That Mr Turley certainly knows how to turn things around. Let me guess, he’s one of those MAGA idiots too.

  17. Gold_Dog908 on

    Is anyone surprised at this? A united Europe is a rival and, as such, a threat to the US hegemony.

  18. EyyYoMikey on

    This article is straight up farcical. Then again, we’ve got a preposterous administration that lives in bizarro world and constantly lies and scams and believes Europe is a rival. The elections can’t come soon enough.

  19. 2trembler3 on

    Seriously, who in the US still cares what Maga turd Turley has to say? Best to ignore.

  20. If American conservatives are whining about you, you’re doing the right thing.

  21. Ambitious-Concern-42 on

    Which is of course, the primary motivation and sole reason Canada is exploring EU membership. Canada just excels at suppressing the God-given rights of Conservatives, Neo-Cons, Nazis, and various other assorted right-wingers, the only category of human with the will and right to exist. All the rest of you, into the mass retraining camps you go! America will and must declare immediate war on all these ridiculous attempts to establish distance from their ultimate destiny: suzerainty and subservience to a Greater American Reich.

    /s, in case you didn’t catch on.

  22. Freedom of speech is one of the cornerstones underpinning the First Amendment to our (U.S.) Constitution even when it gives misguided hacks like Jonathan Turley a voice.

    His statement in the linked article…

    >If the American Republic is to survive another 250 years, it must preserve key rights that the EU has been systematically destroying in Europe — freedom of speech, division of powers and political accountability of decision-makers.

    astounds me.

    I have no expertise in EU laws; however, I am living through the Trump administration and its attacks on our: 1) freedom of speech, 2) division of powers, and 3) political accountability of decision-makers. Turley says nothing about those when voicing his absurd opinions on the oligarch-owned, right-wing propaganda channel FOX News.

  23. aro_plane on

    They are so scared of united europe, it’s hilarious. Can’t pressure the whole bloc, can you? It warms my heart seeing the Republicans seething because they can’t order EU around.

  24. paradigm_shift2027 on

    Nobody cares what Turdley says. He’s proven again & again he’s just a propagandist for the Radical Right.

  25. Treff_the_Cleric on

    Jonathan Turley is a notorious conservative hack who supports Trump. He is prone to conspiratorial thinking, and he absolutely loves attention. We can safely ignore this op-ed. 🤣

  26. Brave_Nerve_6871 on

    Translation: Post -Orban EU will be harder for Trump admin to abuse

  27. « Our revolution was fought against a foreign empire »
    Just like everything else in this trash paper, it isn’t based on history but on moronism.

    « We saw this threat before, and we defeated a world empire. If we are to survive and thrive in this century, we will need to return to our own creation as a republic — to dig deep down and remember who we are as citizens. »
    Hopefully this means they’ll stay home, Monroe doctrine like and will leave the rest of the world alone

  28. Doom_of__Mandos on

    This is the reason Trump showed such support for Brexit with UK. He just wanted to see the UN fractured as much as possible. Everyone needs to rely on US, no one can play ball amongst themselves.

  29. Academic_Dig_1567 on

    This is one of the most ignorant pieces I have ever read.

  30. trainednooob on

    The EU is a threat to US sovereignty to the same degree that the EU is a security threat to Russia … only if you really really want to imagine it

  31. US sovereignty over what?

    **insert goose chase meme**

    _US sovereignty over what?_

  32. WinstonFox on

    Fuck me. Trump/Putin/Bibi are really pumping up Europe as the enemy. You can see where this is going without regime change in the US.

  33. Szabolcs85 on

    It seems that the MAGA-movement does not take kindly of Orbán’s catastrophic defeat.

    Good.

  34. So the bestest country of them all is scared of the europoors?

    Interesting…

  35. realqmaster on

    That’s rich after you had no problems with explicitely threatening annexion of EU territories just some month ago.

    Also, Orban was the epitome of russian assets. It is very telling that you consider less corruption by the Kremlin a threat to the US.

  36. extrastupidone on

    >The irony is that this claimed victory for democracy may fuel the establishment of a global governance system that is neither democratic nor accountable to citizens.

    So…. your imagination. Got it

  37. Miserable-Arm-4787 on

    The easiest possible way to figure out which Americans are Russian assets is by noting who talks positively about Orban.

Leave A Reply