In the UK, where we have the 4th most expensive consumer electricity in the world (and the most expensive industrial electricity), it is true there isnt anywhere near enough storage capacity for solar/wind generated power, so sometimes consumers like me are actually paid to use electricity at about £0.05 per kW/h.
Sea-Celebration2429 on
Finland spend 16 years to build nuclear power plant and when it finally is working, guess what: They are going forward to build another nuclear powerplant, b/c that is the only reliable source in the winter.
Several_Ant_9867 on
Because there are not enough batteries. But that is already changing
V0R88 on
And yet electricity prices follow the gas price so we pay a lot for energy
New-Ranger-8960 on
Same in Greece.
We often have days where renewables can easily power the entire grid for hours and sometimes the entire 24h, but because of the lack of battery storage infrastructure, we’re forced into throwing away massive amounts of clean energy because the grid can’t handle the surplus.
And apart from that, due to the energy pricing model, even when solar and wind are doing the heavy lifting for almost completely free, we end up paying the price of the most expensive source (usually natural gas) because that’s what sets the “clearing price” for the whole market.
It’s a total waste of potential while we still get hit with some of the highest electricity bills in Europe.
BeerPoweredNonsense on
It’s not “wasted” it’s just “not needed right now”.
As long as the economics stack up for PV only selling power outside of summer afternoons (and they will stack up, as installation costs keep going down) then PV installations will continue.
Ima_Wreckyou on
Kurzweil predicted this like 20 years ago. This will continue and within the next 6-8 years we will produce more electricity from solar over the summer than needed globally. Within another 6-8 years it will be enough for winter without seasonal storage. Not even the solar proponents understand this. People are just bad with things that develop exponential.
AustrianMichael on
I have my own solar panels and while during summer it’s plenty, in Central European winter it’s like 1/10th of the output during winter. Exactly when I’d need more power for my heat pump.
I‘m probably going to install an AC in the near future, because you won’t get paid much for energy anyways, so why should I not get some comfort from it
u1604 on
someone tell Bloomberg editors that every sun ray that is not converted into electricity is wasted.
what a stupid title. who cares about some excess electricity if it saves from import energy bills and the economics work out? Any excess electricity is a good problem to have as it will incentivize battery installations and demand shifting.
generic_male0510 on
Sounds like one of them good problems
Novat1993 on
Energy is expensive -> build solar -> energy is too abundant -> build storage -> energy becomes cheap -> demand increase -> energy becomes expensive -> build more solar.
This is the energy loop. And in the past it hit an uneasy equilibrium as the demand for coal first, and then oil matched the supply of those commodities.
With solar/wind/battery being cheaper than fossil fuels. The energy loop will begin over again. Until a new equilibrium is reached.
special-bangeologist on
Nobody talks about consumption
Henry-the-Fern on
Wasted or not, the kWh is still priced at the cost of the highest energy producing material other day, usually natural gas. So at the moment, it’s just for a selected bunch to make great profits
t0xic_sh0t on
Curiously my electric bill only goes up.
AdAncient5201 on
Can someone ELI5 why that doesn’t mean that the energy mix is at 100% renewables then? Wouldn’t it cost energy producers like gas plants lots of money?
crisco000 on
How does the EU have some of the most expensive energy bills per household while simultaneously wasting energy bc too much is produced?
KofFinland on
In Finland the electricity price is negative when there is lots of wind. The wind farms are actually paying that someone takes their electricity.
It is not a surprise that they are making a huge loss (around 244 million loss with a bit over 500 million turnover in 2024) as when wind really blows, electricity price is negative, and when wind does not blow, the energy price is high because there is not many conventional plants left to produce the energy (we lack around 3000MW in Finland during winter when it is cold and wind does not blow), but no wind production.
Of course, solar is similar. When there is lots of solar available, energy prices will be negative.
“Kauppalehden selvitys lataa madonluvut Suomen tuulivoiman kannattavuudelle. Tuulisähkö on halpaa kuluttajille, mutta se on syönyt liiketoimintaa. Vuonna 2024 tuulivoima jauhoi yli puolen miljardin euron liikevaihdolla nettotappiota 244 miljoonaa euroa.”
li_shi on
It just means that storage hasn’t catch up yet.
Upbeat_Parking_7794 on
Aren’t gas stations and coal stations and even dams stopped when not needed?
What is the difference? The only I see is that the sun is free and after the initial investment makes sense to just sell the generated electricity, even for a low price.
Moosplauze on
I have a quote for PV for my house to install 24 PV modules for 11.4kWp and a battery with 6.9kWh capcatity for 21.5k€ including all installation and everything. Expensive but will make relatively self-sufficient (especially once I have an electric car that I can also use as battery) and will break even after ~15 years (I hope).
OTee_D on
Paywall
Hertje73 on
Then why are my bills so huge
TbR78 on
paywall crap
jcrestor on
I think batteries could be a solution.
notaredditer13 on
There goes your LCOE.
pouetpouetcamion2 on
ou plutot l énergie solaire n est pas fournie au moment ou l on en a besoin, c est donc parfaitement inutile.
debackerl on
EVs are quite attractive if you can charge home during daytime… Or you may mine bitcoins, but thr equipment isn’t that cheap anymore, I didn’t do the math on that one
gourmetguy2000 on
It’s so stupid this isn’t being used to make hydrogen
Motor_Educator_2706 on
Isn’t this what nuclear promised? Electricity too cheap to meter
dcmso on
Wasted?
Its the Sun..
Alexandre_Man on
Good
Raschlenitel on
I think we can use extra electricity to obtain hydrogen and use it instead of gas
M2dX on
Im Land der Windmühlen, aka Ostfriesland, wird gerade alles mit Batterien vollgeplastert.
hamstar_potato on
So why have electricity prices gone up?
dakjelle on
I’m sure this article was well researched and understands how this stuff works?
yankdevil on
Batteries are really cheap folks. Personally I dump excess solar in my EV, but do want to get a bigger home battery.
38 commenti
In the UK, where we have the 4th most expensive consumer electricity in the world (and the most expensive industrial electricity), it is true there isnt anywhere near enough storage capacity for solar/wind generated power, so sometimes consumers like me are actually paid to use electricity at about £0.05 per kW/h.
Finland spend 16 years to build nuclear power plant and when it finally is working, guess what: They are going forward to build another nuclear powerplant, b/c that is the only reliable source in the winter.
Because there are not enough batteries. But that is already changing
And yet electricity prices follow the gas price so we pay a lot for energy
Same in Greece.
We often have days where renewables can easily power the entire grid for hours and sometimes the entire 24h, but because of the lack of battery storage infrastructure, we’re forced into throwing away massive amounts of clean energy because the grid can’t handle the surplus.
And apart from that, due to the energy pricing model, even when solar and wind are doing the heavy lifting for almost completely free, we end up paying the price of the most expensive source (usually natural gas) because that’s what sets the “clearing price” for the whole market.
It’s a total waste of potential while we still get hit with some of the highest electricity bills in Europe.
It’s not “wasted” it’s just “not needed right now”.
As long as the economics stack up for PV only selling power outside of summer afternoons (and they will stack up, as installation costs keep going down) then PV installations will continue.
Kurzweil predicted this like 20 years ago. This will continue and within the next 6-8 years we will produce more electricity from solar over the summer than needed globally. Within another 6-8 years it will be enough for winter without seasonal storage. Not even the solar proponents understand this. People are just bad with things that develop exponential.
I have my own solar panels and while during summer it’s plenty, in Central European winter it’s like 1/10th of the output during winter. Exactly when I’d need more power for my heat pump.
I‘m probably going to install an AC in the near future, because you won’t get paid much for energy anyways, so why should I not get some comfort from it
someone tell Bloomberg editors that every sun ray that is not converted into electricity is wasted.
what a stupid title. who cares about some excess electricity if it saves from import energy bills and the economics work out? Any excess electricity is a good problem to have as it will incentivize battery installations and demand shifting.
Sounds like one of them good problems
Energy is expensive -> build solar -> energy is too abundant -> build storage -> energy becomes cheap -> demand increase -> energy becomes expensive -> build more solar.
This is the energy loop. And in the past it hit an uneasy equilibrium as the demand for coal first, and then oil matched the supply of those commodities.
With solar/wind/battery being cheaper than fossil fuels. The energy loop will begin over again. Until a new equilibrium is reached.
Nobody talks about consumption
Wasted or not, the kWh is still priced at the cost of the highest energy producing material other day, usually natural gas. So at the moment, it’s just for a selected bunch to make great profits
Curiously my electric bill only goes up.
Can someone ELI5 why that doesn’t mean that the energy mix is at 100% renewables then? Wouldn’t it cost energy producers like gas plants lots of money?
How does the EU have some of the most expensive energy bills per household while simultaneously wasting energy bc too much is produced?
In Finland the electricity price is negative when there is lots of wind. The wind farms are actually paying that someone takes their electricity.
It is not a surprise that they are making a huge loss (around 244 million loss with a bit over 500 million turnover in 2024) as when wind really blows, electricity price is negative, and when wind does not blow, the energy price is high because there is not many conventional plants left to produce the energy (we lack around 3000MW in Finland during winter when it is cold and wind does not blow), but no wind production.
Of course, solar is similar. When there is lots of solar available, energy prices will be negative.
–
Here is link, use google translate if you care:
[https://www.kauppalehti.fi/uutiset/a/45ffb109-ec3f-4d61-b77a-b041988ea96a](https://www.kauppalehti.fi/uutiset/a/45ffb109-ec3f-4d61-b77a-b041988ea96a)
“Kauppalehden selvitys lataa madonluvut Suomen tuulivoiman kannattavuudelle. Tuulisähkö on halpaa kuluttajille, mutta se on syönyt liiketoimintaa. Vuonna 2024 tuulivoima jauhoi yli puolen miljardin euron liikevaihdolla nettotappiota 244 miljoonaa euroa.”
It just means that storage hasn’t catch up yet.
Aren’t gas stations and coal stations and even dams stopped when not needed?
What is the difference? The only I see is that the sun is free and after the initial investment makes sense to just sell the generated electricity, even for a low price.
I have a quote for PV for my house to install 24 PV modules for 11.4kWp and a battery with 6.9kWh capcatity for 21.5k€ including all installation and everything. Expensive but will make relatively self-sufficient (especially once I have an electric car that I can also use as battery) and will break even after ~15 years (I hope).
Paywall
Then why are my bills so huge
paywall crap
I think batteries could be a solution.
There goes your LCOE.
ou plutot l énergie solaire n est pas fournie au moment ou l on en a besoin, c est donc parfaitement inutile.
EVs are quite attractive if you can charge home during daytime… Or you may mine bitcoins, but thr equipment isn’t that cheap anymore, I didn’t do the math on that one
It’s so stupid this isn’t being used to make hydrogen
Isn’t this what nuclear promised? Electricity too cheap to meter
Wasted?
Its the Sun..
Good
I think we can use extra electricity to obtain hydrogen and use it instead of gas
Im Land der Windmühlen, aka Ostfriesland, wird gerade alles mit Batterien vollgeplastert.
So why have electricity prices gone up?
I’m sure this article was well researched and understands how this stuff works?
Batteries are really cheap folks. Personally I dump excess solar in my EV, but do want to get a bigger home battery.
How about some electric airplanes?
I feel that everytime i fart