article sums up everything that is wrong with our legal system
elessar8787 on
Life in prison would solve the reoffending.
Tigeire on
“While he has undertaken different courses of treatment over the years, his bid to break his alcohol dependence has not been successful.”
Releasing someone like this back into society just sets them up for the same failure.
Needs to be in some sort of controlled environment where there is no access to alcohol.
wipingabrownmarker on
He’s in Midlands but from Kerry so he’s obviously a sex offender too as they are all housed in Midlands
Redtit14 on
Was wondering what happened to Steve Bruce.
Otherwise-Winner9643 on
OK, so I read the article. None of his crimes are violent, but they are all alcohol fuelled. Every person he has encountered says he is a lovely man when sober.
My GOD he’s 53. I would have said 75 before reading the article!
bobbyB2022 on
Soft on crime.
Ireland_Con on
He should never see what’s on the outside of a prison wall again. Lock him up until he passes away in his cell.
MMAwannabe on
Are people who are commenting reading the article?
Im usually the person arguing for harsher sentencing but I’m surprised so many people feel so strongly that this man should be locked up for good considering the background to the whole story. (Clear addiction problems, non violent crimes)
anna_pescova on
….but it’s his culture..
bingybong22 on
This guy should be locked up – not in some nasty jail, it in a place where he’s safe, but has no access to drink.
I’d lock up all of the junkies on the streets of Dublin in the same place
Future-Cat2521 on
Unfortunately I can’t read it so I’ll make up my own story.
Melodic-Chocolate-53 on
Irish penal system, let’s try the same old thing over and over again until it works.
bulbispire on
Not going to be long before he develops dementia and ends up in a nursing home
bulbispire on
Comments full of people proposing flawed absolute solutions.
If you allow people like this to be locked up indefinitely for petty crime, it’s a human rights abuse. If you do nothing, it’s a human rights abuse. You can’t force addiction treatment because that doesn’t work. You can’t lock someone up in a mental institution for addiction like this – the law specifically forbids it.
The reality is: hard cases make bad law, and there’s no easy solution to a case like this. Just dozens of trained professionals, family members, friends and neighbours who are doing their best. Eventually he’ll get sick and die, and that’ll be the end of it.
18 commenti
article sums up everything that is wrong with our legal system
Life in prison would solve the reoffending.
“While he has undertaken different courses of treatment over the years, his bid to break his alcohol dependence has not been successful.”
Releasing someone like this back into society just sets them up for the same failure.
Needs to be in some sort of controlled environment where there is no access to alcohol.
He’s in Midlands but from Kerry so he’s obviously a sex offender too as they are all housed in Midlands
Was wondering what happened to Steve Bruce.
OK, so I read the article. None of his crimes are violent, but they are all alcohol fuelled. Every person he has encountered says he is a lovely man when sober.
Surely, the Scandinavian approach to his alcohol addiction would make sense, using drugs like Naltrexone. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/04/the-irrationality-of-alcoholics-anonymous/386255/
[removed]
My GOD he’s 53. I would have said 75 before reading the article!
Soft on crime.
He should never see what’s on the outside of a prison wall again. Lock him up until he passes away in his cell.
Are people who are commenting reading the article?
Im usually the person arguing for harsher sentencing but I’m surprised so many people feel so strongly that this man should be locked up for good considering the background to the whole story. (Clear addiction problems, non violent crimes)
….but it’s his culture..
This guy should be locked up – not in some nasty jail, it in a place where he’s safe, but has no access to drink.
I’d lock up all of the junkies on the streets of Dublin in the same place
Unfortunately I can’t read it so I’ll make up my own story.
Irish penal system, let’s try the same old thing over and over again until it works.
Not going to be long before he develops dementia and ends up in a nursing home
Comments full of people proposing flawed absolute solutions.
If you allow people like this to be locked up indefinitely for petty crime, it’s a human rights abuse. If you do nothing, it’s a human rights abuse. You can’t force addiction treatment because that doesn’t work. You can’t lock someone up in a mental institution for addiction like this – the law specifically forbids it.
The reality is: hard cases make bad law, and there’s no easy solution to a case like this. Just dozens of trained professionals, family members, friends and neighbours who are doing their best. Eventually he’ll get sick and die, and that’ll be the end of it.
Mental health services need to be better.