Gli scienziati avvertono la ritirata antidepressiva minimizzata da studi “finanziati dall’industria”

    https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/antidepressant-withdrawal-symptoms-study-long-term-risks-b2789401.html

    di tylerthe-theatre

    Share.

    18 commenti

    1. Branwolf on

      Yeah it ain’t fun, I arguably came off venlafaxine faster than I should have, and it was brutal, wish I can my medical cannabis back then, would have helped wonders with the intense insomnia from the withdrawals.

    2. AncientStaff6602 on

      I went cold turkey and that wasn’t fun at all. I count myself lucky.

      Personally the therapy I went for was far better for me than the anti-depressants

    3. goodchia on

      I ended up in hospital trying to come off of an SNRI I was put on to help with a sleep issue. This issue needs to be everywhere and widely understood.

      If anyone wants more information or support in safely coming off SSRI’s and SNRI’s whilst minimising side effects then please google Dr Mark Horowitz. He literally wrote the [new] book on safely tapering off SSRI’s and SNRI’s, there are entirely new guidelines that haven’t yet filtered down to most GP’s. His YouTube channel is a fantastic resource – Outro Health.

    4. Majestic-Pea1982 on

      Yep, no doctor has ever warned me about anti-depressant withdrawal when prescribing and it’s fucking brutal.

    5. Jaykwonder on

      Being in a work meeting and my brain is zapping every 20 seconds, never again.

    6. Few-Display-3242 on

      Whoever is in charge of PR at Big Pharma inc. deserves some recognition. They managed to shift public opinion so much that we went from most people being sceptical of the industry to people demanding involuntary vaccination in about half a generation.

      About 70% of people on antidepressants shouldn’t be on them – there is nothing wrong with their neurochemistry, it’s just that life sucks for them right now… They need social support, a relationship, a dog, some new healthy habits; a little pill with a chicken on it is not going to change that.

      Eta: I work in preclinical pharmaceutical development and it is a very sketchy field. Things go wrong, outliers are included/excluded at will, statistical analyses are ‘tweaked’. I’m aware of at least two current clinical trials that are being conducted without any consideration of the preclinical findings leading to increased adverse event rates. Sex-differences in particular need more attention – it’s common to find AEs at a higher rate in one of the sexes.

    7. FibonacciNeuron on

      Horowitz and Moncrieff are outcasts, they are opinionated, while the actual study is performed by serious academics. Of course they are supported by pharma, they are the best, why wouldn’t they be? It happens in all fields if you are the best, you get funded. That funding had no influence on this study though

    8. 420stonks69 on

      There’s so much to unpack here

      – I generally agree with the authors of the Independent article that short term studies don’t give us the best view of withdrawal effects for those coming off antidepressants after very long periods

      – The authors of the Independent article are a bit of a joke in academic circles. Their entire careers are based on predictably shallow criticism of various concepts/approaches in psychiatry. Funnily enough, despite what they say about the conflicts of interest regarding supposed financial incentives for the authors (more on that below), they themselves are selling books/talks etc from the point of view of being anti-medications. The exact thing they are criticising the authors of the research article for.

      – Their criticisms regarding ‘close ties to industry’ are insidious and underhand. Those of us who work in the field know that for a large number of researchers, it’s right to be open about COIs but I know for a fact that the particular study they are criticising was not funded, guided, or edited by anyone in industry. The general public have a very poor, conspiratorial understanding of how to interpret COIs.

      – In general I don’t agree with the conclusions of the paper and would probably have done things differently had I been involved.

      – If you’re someone who has had bad side effects withdrawing from antidepressants then I feel for you. I had them too having come off several antidepressants. Studies like this don’t help for the minority of those who do experience this, especially those on medications for a long time. I wish the paper had looked at more long-term data by way of comparison rather than only looking at short studies and not considering how this may have been interpreted/reported.

    9. Few-Improvement-5655 on

      So I in no way recommend this, but just for the sake of sharing experiences I cold turkey’d sertraline (SSRI) after being on it for, I want to say, well over a decade, and the only withdrawal I got was a persistent dizziness for about two months.

    10. lubbockin on

      “Just a short course of antidepressants..”

      decades later they are still stuck on them.

    11. Yeah it is, coming off various SSRIs (prozac, Sertraline, .etc) side effects not that bad, coming off SNRIs (Venlafaxine) oh boy that is a ride and a half and still feeling the effects nearly 18 months since coming off.

    12. ScientistFit6451 on

      Wait until you learn that the epidemic in chronic depression might be down to the introduction and chronification of neurotransmitter dysfunctions caused by SSRIs via them modifying your serotonine metabolism and serotonine receptors. In other words, if you want to be cynical, the industry might just engineer its own consumer base by hooking them up on drugs that many of them can’t come off easily.

    13. ButterMyMuffin on

      Coming off venlafaxine was the worst experience ever, laid in bed and the brain zaps felt like I was jumping off the bed. Never tried heroin but I feel it would of been easier getting off that

    14. NathanDavie on

      Used speed to get myself off SSRIs a few years back. Worked really well. I’m back on them now but whenever I want to stop it’ll be amphetamines that I use to avoid the devastating withdrawal.

    15. InTheEndEntropyWins on

      This article is soo wrong, SSRIs aren’t addictive and don’t have withdrawal symptoms. Maybe they are talking about discontinuation syndrome /s

      [https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/25218-antidepressant-discontinuation-syndrome](https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/25218-antidepressant-discontinuation-syndrome)

      And pharmaceutical companies have successfully redefined addiction so that their drugs don’t count as being addictive even though you can have a physical dependence such that stopping can put you in hospital.

      When that original review was posted. I called bullshit and suggested that they must be looking at industry funded studies of the withdrawal effects after a few months of usage not long term usage. Turns out I was right.

      >A new review of antidepressant withdrawal effects – written by academics, many of whom have close ties to drug manufacturers – risks underestimating the potential harms to long-term antidepressant users by focusing on short-term, industry-funded studies.

    16. panguy87 on

      This is one of several reasons why i didn’t want to go on antidepressants for my MH. Potential for permanent side effects even upon ceasing medication was the number 1 reason opted against them.

    17. Shearsy09 on

      They don’t provide doses low enough to allow you to come off them safely where there are groups dedicated to “bead counting” just to help support those looking to come off them.

      The withdrawals can be literally debilitating.

    Leave A Reply