Is it really their responsibility? I know we shouldn’t really defend companies of such scale, but I don’t see how this makes the situation different. The government and corruption are what caused this, not Google.
Forsaken-Cell1848 on
It’s cool that Google offers such a service, but shouldn’t the early warning and call to evacuation be the job of, you know, the fucking government?
aps105aps105 on
BBC always find new ways to criticize foreign government. have to give them the credit, creative journalism.
Complex-Safety-2389 on
Tired and read it as God failed too warm them . Oops
iboreddd on
This has absolutely nothing to do with Google. What happened was not just one earthquake but two massive ones on the same day. The scale of the disaster was enormous. Let’s break it down into before and after the quake.
Major earthquakes were already expected along this fault line, just like the one currently anticipated in Istanbul. Yet the government took no real precautions. Urban renewal efforts were insufficient. And when it comes to preparedness (emergency shelters, designated assembly areas, and essential equipment), we are still drastically underprepared.
After the earthquake, while people were desperately trying to reach loved ones, the government chose to restrict social media under the pretext of fighting disinformation. The military, which could have made a critical difference with its resources and expertise, was not deployed. Erdoğan’s long-standing hostility toward the armed forces once again turned into a liability in a moment of national crisis.
Search and rescue efforts were carried out mostly by volunteers. Many victims did not die during the quake itself but later, trapped under rubble for hours or even days without help. The death toll remains suspicious. The relevant minister accidentally mentioned the number 130,000 during a live broadcast (more than twice the official figure). Thousands of people are still missing. Tragically, many were likely buried with the debris and never recorded.
When Erdoğan finally visited the disaster zone weeks later, his first reaction was to lash out at the opposition and citizens who asked, “Where is the government?” In light of all this, blaming Google is absurd.
Now the country is being consumed by wildfires. The government acts as if it is deliberately doing nothing. It would not be surprising if the scorched lands are soon turned into tourism or mining zones, using powers Erdoğan granted himself just a few years ago.
TheoryOfDevolution on
I too have failed to notify millions of Turkey of the earthquake. My bad guys.
Ok-Pineapple2365 on
I guess they had their notifications off!
CertainMiddle2382 on
That’s the reason despite the promises since 30 years, no diagnostic/treatment/management algorithmic help exists in healthcare software.
Liability.
dziki_z_lasu on
Next article proposal: McDonald’s failed to fix the hunger problem in sub-saharian Africa /s
DiBalls on
Government responsibility private company may assist. Don’t ask the US they don’t have any clue.
Boundless_Chaos_108 on
How is it Google’s fault? It is the government’s fault.
Secuter on
The *real* failure lies with the Turkish government and the corruption that allowed this.
Atiturozt on
People saying it’s not Google’s responsibility don’t realize the article is about android phones and how they push alert notifications. It’s not google’s fault people died but it’s google’s job to make a working android notification system.
C4-BlueCat on
> Google’s early warning system was in place and live on the day of the quakes – however it underestimated how strong the earthquakes were.
14 commenti
Is it really their responsibility? I know we shouldn’t really defend companies of such scale, but I don’t see how this makes the situation different. The government and corruption are what caused this, not Google.
It’s cool that Google offers such a service, but shouldn’t the early warning and call to evacuation be the job of, you know, the fucking government?
BBC always find new ways to criticize foreign government. have to give them the credit, creative journalism.
Tired and read it as God failed too warm them . Oops
This has absolutely nothing to do with Google. What happened was not just one earthquake but two massive ones on the same day. The scale of the disaster was enormous. Let’s break it down into before and after the quake.
Major earthquakes were already expected along this fault line, just like the one currently anticipated in Istanbul. Yet the government took no real precautions. Urban renewal efforts were insufficient. And when it comes to preparedness (emergency shelters, designated assembly areas, and essential equipment), we are still drastically underprepared.
After the earthquake, while people were desperately trying to reach loved ones, the government chose to restrict social media under the pretext of fighting disinformation. The military, which could have made a critical difference with its resources and expertise, was not deployed. Erdoğan’s long-standing hostility toward the armed forces once again turned into a liability in a moment of national crisis.
Search and rescue efforts were carried out mostly by volunteers. Many victims did not die during the quake itself but later, trapped under rubble for hours or even days without help. The death toll remains suspicious. The relevant minister accidentally mentioned the number 130,000 during a live broadcast (more than twice the official figure). Thousands of people are still missing. Tragically, many were likely buried with the debris and never recorded.
When Erdoğan finally visited the disaster zone weeks later, his first reaction was to lash out at the opposition and citizens who asked, “Where is the government?” In light of all this, blaming Google is absurd.
Now the country is being consumed by wildfires. The government acts as if it is deliberately doing nothing. It would not be surprising if the scorched lands are soon turned into tourism or mining zones, using powers Erdoğan granted himself just a few years ago.
I too have failed to notify millions of Turkey of the earthquake. My bad guys.
I guess they had their notifications off!
That’s the reason despite the promises since 30 years, no diagnostic/treatment/management algorithmic help exists in healthcare software.
Liability.
Next article proposal: McDonald’s failed to fix the hunger problem in sub-saharian Africa /s
Government responsibility private company may assist. Don’t ask the US they don’t have any clue.
How is it Google’s fault? It is the government’s fault.
The *real* failure lies with the Turkish government and the corruption that allowed this.
People saying it’s not Google’s responsibility don’t realize the article is about android phones and how they push alert notifications. It’s not google’s fault people died but it’s google’s job to make a working android notification system.
> Google’s early warning system was in place and live on the day of the quakes – however it underestimated how strong the earthquakes were.