Where are the permanent positions? They don’t have enough positions for their own researchers. How will they accommodate more? Especially those who were paid much better in US?
VigorousElk on
Sure. If we ignore the lower funding, lack of tenured positions, lower salaries … Americans from all sorts of professional backgrounds frequently look to Europe as a place to move and escape the US’ problems – then they do their research, run into Europe’s own problems and reconsider. Most of all due to the gap in (disposable) income, especially for graduates.
madeleineann on
European wages are a joke compared to the wages offered in even the poorer states. People seem to forget that France and the UK are on par with Mississipi and Germany would also be one of the poorest states on a per/capita basis.
I’m sure many professionals would love to move to Europe, but we are just not competitive enough compared to America. It’s definitely one of our biggest issues.
VillagePatrick on
Lower wages yes, but affordable healthcare and just the overall benefit of not being in the U.S. anymore. Not everything is about money.
KHolito on
How?
There are virtually no tenure positions open, post docs are already scarce, and basically any job in academia is underpaid.
HowFarIt on
Russia too 😘
h0ls86 on
It’s time to brain drain a country that is galloping towards authoritarianism, huh? Well I’m all for that.
theWireFan1983 on
Europe seriously does think highly of itself…
JazzlikeChemical2041 on
These comments miss the biggest factor — language. Most American researchers do not speak French, German, and the rest of the languages of Europe
WP27I on
Except Europe pays researchers like shit, someone even at Cambridge can often expect not even 40k
edit: why is this flagged as controversial you idiots, you can easily look up postdoc and higher wages and they’re fucking horrible in Europe, you’d be better off even in Canada or Australia, postdocs in Australia get almost UK full professor pay, nobody can do this for free, Europe has to actually do something to earn researchers back
Specialist-Body7700 on
Are you fucking serious? My friend was working at her lab as a researcher while doing a biotechnology PHD and she made 1400 € a month and did insane hours. These eurocrat politicians are so out of touch it’s insulting.
It’s great that you want to attract american talent but at least have a honest look at the precariousness we face here, particularly in southern europe. It’s no wonder that people quit these careers.
paraquinone on
And by “says” I mean “said like a month ago”.
ramxquake on
How would they afford it?
StrokeOfGrimdark on
Unpopular opinion: Many aren’t the sort of researchers we need tho. Don’t get me wrong: social researchers are great too, but we already got plenty of those in Europe. What we need are tech researchers. Most tech researches are fine in the US momentarily and won’t be looking to relocate.
MethyleneBlueEnjoyer on
Europe is utterly unprepared to reap the benefits of this windfall. A prospective researcher who actually gets serious about moving out of the US and starts doing their homework will find in Europe, once they get past the PR, a devastated market, both public and private.
Sure, some will look past that, but anyone whose life is basically not entirely politics at this point will probably just relocate to some blue state instead.
Basically, it’s raining money and Europe isn’t even carrying a purse let alone a huge basket, so it’ll have to make do with whatever it can carry in its pockets.
MrOphicer on
Then they hear how much it pays here and laugh, go back, and profess love to Trump. People act like scientists, for some reason, belong to a different kind of humans that re incapable of the greatest human vices.
OortBelt on
Reverse Paperclip ! Reverse Paperclip ! 🗣️🗣️
wannabe-physicist on
Throw some money behind that talk first. The EU doesn’t have enough funding for EU researchers, forget Americans.
Why do people keep bringing up wages when the issue is researchers in USA facing high risk of defunding or losing their jobs?
lihr__ on
Man, show me some fucking serious investment in research then! Show me more grants to compete for. Funding you have to fight for, but it’s huge. Because that is why scientists go to the US. Besides higher salaries, the US system provides an unparalleled amount of money to actually do cutting edge experiments with cutting edge equipment which is fucking expensive. This how progress happens.
Boundish91 on
Reverse operation Paperclip.
just_damz on
I was fucking waiting for this. Nothing easier to drain the brains out of a nation when you kill research funds.
Dalnore on
Hard to believe. The European academia is extremely competitive and underpaid already.
Depends on the type of researchers that will come. If they are researchers on robotics, micro and nano fabrication, additive manufacturing, advanced materials, or like them yup. They could be a good opportunity for EU.
bluAstrid on
You the place where knowledge is cherished and celebrated?
Chaiboiii on
Hey hey Canada wants some of those too please
txipper on
Europe needs to fund university research on the US model and they’ll get thousands of applicants.
IcyExtent3740 on
Bildung steht halt nicht auf der Prioritätenliste ganz oben.
TheGoalkeeper on
In industry yes. Not in academia though.
Still-Bookkeeper4456 on
I don’t think that lady (and people in this sub apparently) realizes how much better US universities are compared to Europe.
Harvard endowment is around 50B USD. UC Berkeley has a parking lot for Nobel prizes. About a quarter of MIT physics professors have a wolf medal or a Nobel prize.
European universities are a joke. Salaries, campuses, labs, grants, nothing compares. Wishful thinking doesn’t get you anywhere.
Glass-North8050 on
Can it be haven for local researchers as a start?
sirbradleyfloof on
I’m a junior scientist in biotech who has been laid off twice in two years (feeling quite annoyed with capitalism…), have been wanting to go back for a PhD in drug delivery or virology for a while now, but universities are in a panic as grants are being randomly frozen and major funding cuts up in the air. Not only are graduate admissions dropping dramatically, but I would hate to be halfway into my phd just to get screwed by finances being slashed. Been looking at universities outside the US for this reason (also would love to live abroad, learn a new language).
I’ve also been trying to fight the administration here with protests, boycott, volunteering locally, and would feel guilty running away to another country to take a student position away from a citizen there. But maybe it could be a win-win to brain drain the US and contribute scientifically to strengthen your lovely countries over in Europe. I don’t know, tbd.
Dr_J_Doe on
Could be, but won’t
Efficient_Falcon_402 on
Kinda like when the Americans took all the Nazi scientists after WWII.
ActualDW on
Don’t think many top people are going to sign up for a 60% drop in pay and a 30% increase in taxes….
39 commenti
Reverse the brain drain
Where are the permanent positions? They don’t have enough positions for their own researchers. How will they accommodate more? Especially those who were paid much better in US?
Sure. If we ignore the lower funding, lack of tenured positions, lower salaries … Americans from all sorts of professional backgrounds frequently look to Europe as a place to move and escape the US’ problems – then they do their research, run into Europe’s own problems and reconsider. Most of all due to the gap in (disposable) income, especially for graduates.
European wages are a joke compared to the wages offered in even the poorer states. People seem to forget that France and the UK are on par with Mississipi and Germany would also be one of the poorest states on a per/capita basis.
I’m sure many professionals would love to move to Europe, but we are just not competitive enough compared to America. It’s definitely one of our biggest issues.
Lower wages yes, but affordable healthcare and just the overall benefit of not being in the U.S. anymore. Not everything is about money.
How?
There are virtually no tenure positions open, post docs are already scarce, and basically any job in academia is underpaid.
Russia too 😘
It’s time to brain drain a country that is galloping towards authoritarianism, huh? Well I’m all for that.
Europe seriously does think highly of itself…
These comments miss the biggest factor — language. Most American researchers do not speak French, German, and the rest of the languages of Europe
Except Europe pays researchers like shit, someone even at Cambridge can often expect not even 40k
edit: why is this flagged as controversial you idiots, you can easily look up postdoc and higher wages and they’re fucking horrible in Europe, you’d be better off even in Canada or Australia, postdocs in Australia get almost UK full professor pay, nobody can do this for free, Europe has to actually do something to earn researchers back
Are you fucking serious? My friend was working at her lab as a researcher while doing a biotechnology PHD and she made 1400 € a month and did insane hours. These eurocrat politicians are so out of touch it’s insulting.
It’s great that you want to attract american talent but at least have a honest look at the precariousness we face here, particularly in southern europe. It’s no wonder that people quit these careers.
And by “says” I mean “said like a month ago”.
How would they afford it?
Unpopular opinion: Many aren’t the sort of researchers we need tho. Don’t get me wrong: social researchers are great too, but we already got plenty of those in Europe. What we need are tech researchers. Most tech researches are fine in the US momentarily and won’t be looking to relocate.
Europe is utterly unprepared to reap the benefits of this windfall. A prospective researcher who actually gets serious about moving out of the US and starts doing their homework will find in Europe, once they get past the PR, a devastated market, both public and private.
Sure, some will look past that, but anyone whose life is basically not entirely politics at this point will probably just relocate to some blue state instead.
Basically, it’s raining money and Europe isn’t even carrying a purse let alone a huge basket, so it’ll have to make do with whatever it can carry in its pockets.
Then they hear how much it pays here and laugh, go back, and profess love to Trump. People act like scientists, for some reason, belong to a different kind of humans that re incapable of the greatest human vices.
Reverse Paperclip ! Reverse Paperclip ! 🗣️🗣️
Throw some money behind that talk first. The EU doesn’t have enough funding for EU researchers, forget Americans.
https://www.reddit.com/r/chemistry/comments/1ea62ok/rchemistry_salary_survey_2024/
I doubt that.
Why do people keep bringing up wages when the issue is researchers in USA facing high risk of defunding or losing their jobs?
Man, show me some fucking serious investment in research then! Show me more grants to compete for. Funding you have to fight for, but it’s huge. Because that is why scientists go to the US. Besides higher salaries, the US system provides an unparalleled amount of money to actually do cutting edge experiments with cutting edge equipment which is fucking expensive. This how progress happens.
Reverse operation Paperclip.
I was fucking waiting for this. Nothing easier to drain the brains out of a nation when you kill research funds.
Hard to believe. The European academia is extremely competitive and underpaid already.
Brain Drain 2: Electric Boogaloo
No it won’t. Science budgets are getting cut all over Europe. Horizon Europe is [also getting cut](https://era.gv.at/news-items/council-and-parliament-reach-agreement-on-eu-budget-2025/).
Depends on the type of researchers that will come. If they are researchers on robotics, micro and nano fabrication, additive manufacturing, advanced materials, or like them yup. They could be a good opportunity for EU.
You the place where knowledge is cherished and celebrated?
Hey hey Canada wants some of those too please
Europe needs to fund university research on the US model and they’ll get thousands of applicants.
Bildung steht halt nicht auf der Prioritätenliste ganz oben.
In industry yes. Not in academia though.
I don’t think that lady (and people in this sub apparently) realizes how much better US universities are compared to Europe.
Harvard endowment is around 50B USD. UC Berkeley has a parking lot for Nobel prizes. About a quarter of MIT physics professors have a wolf medal or a Nobel prize.
European universities are a joke. Salaries, campuses, labs, grants, nothing compares. Wishful thinking doesn’t get you anywhere.
Can it be haven for local researchers as a start?
I’m a junior scientist in biotech who has been laid off twice in two years (feeling quite annoyed with capitalism…), have been wanting to go back for a PhD in drug delivery or virology for a while now, but universities are in a panic as grants are being randomly frozen and major funding cuts up in the air. Not only are graduate admissions dropping dramatically, but I would hate to be halfway into my phd just to get screwed by finances being slashed. Been looking at universities outside the US for this reason (also would love to live abroad, learn a new language).
I’ve also been trying to fight the administration here with protests, boycott, volunteering locally, and would feel guilty running away to another country to take a student position away from a citizen there. But maybe it could be a win-win to brain drain the US and contribute scientifically to strengthen your lovely countries over in Europe. I don’t know, tbd.
Could be, but won’t
Kinda like when the Americans took all the Nazi scientists after WWII.
Don’t think many top people are going to sign up for a 60% drop in pay and a 30% increase in taxes….